Extra Goodie

58 Reviews

Extra Goodie makes a clean lash serum to promote longer, thicker, and healthier lashes.

What is Thingtesting?

Thingtesting is an unbiased place to research and review internet-born brands — because honest reviews help us all shop better. Learn more.

Average rating from 8 users
Would recommend it to a friend

Extra Goodie Reviews

🤝Friends with Extra Goodie

I've tried other lash serums that made my eyes sting (I wear contacts), caused pigmentation under my eyes, etc. While I saw some results from those, they were short-term because my user experience was otherwise so poor, and I never ended up re-purchasing. I'm on my 3rd or 4th bottle of Extra Goodie, and I always have a back-up waiting. The applicator doesn't load on too much serum (it doesn't seep into my eyes, and I'm able to put it on even without a mirror), the serum dries quickly enough to use before mascara, and I feel good about using such a clean formula. I probably get complimented on my eyelashes now at least once a week - even on Zoom. They are longer, thicker, darker, and more plentiful - which is saying something for a typical Asian lash. When I curl them, they just about hit my eyebrows, and my mascara goes on clump-free. I feel like a commercial.


Offer gift-wrapping for gift orders! EG makes a great gift because longer, healthier lashes (and brows) is something everyone wants, but no one would think to ask for.

Lovely customer supportGood for gifts 🎁High qualityInnovative productWorth the money 💸Travel friendly ✈️Works really well
Mia D's review of Extra Goodie
5 days ago

I was a little hesitant to pick the lash serum up because of the price, and I’d never used anything more than castor oil to condition my eyelashes before - but I am OBSESSED. It’s insane how much longer my lashes have become since I started using this. They almost don’t feel real! They feel generally healthier too. This is 10000% something I’ll purchase again and again.


Wish there was some kind of stopper to prevent spillage, or maybe a way to more easily tell the top of the tube from the bottom (colour? Shape?). I accidentally opened mine upside down in the dark (you’re supposed to apply before bed), and spilled some product out. That was definitely user error but thought I would share in case.

Cool look & feelWorth the money 💸Fun unboxing 📦Works really well
5 days ago

After wearing for lash extensions for years, I decided to give my natural lashes a break….EXTRA GOODIE to the rescue!!! Easy to use, great for sensitive eyes and has helped strengthen my natural lashes. I can proudly say it’s been 2 years without lash extensions and I am loving it more and more everyday. So thankful for this product!


If it’s not broken.. don’t fix it :p

Good for gifts 🎁High qualityWorth the money 💸Custom personalizationTravel friendly ✈️Works really wellEco-friendly packagingLove the brand's mission 💕
6 days ago

This lash serum actually works!!! I consistently applied the serum before bed and my lashes have grown considerably thicker and longer. I’ve notice that my lashes shed less frequently now. Have even bought this for my mom, sister and friends!

Works really well
8 days ago

EG lash serum is without a doubt one of my holy grail products. It took only a few weeks of consistent use to see a difference. Being someone who prefers to wear little to no makeup, this is a must-have. Even without mascara, my lashes look full, thick and miles long.

High qualityInnovative productCool look & feelWorth the money 💸Travel friendly ✈️Works really wellLuxury
16 days ago

Extra Goodie serums are my go-to! I saw results within 3 weeks of consistent use. I love ending my morning and nighttime routine with the easy application of these serums. Who doesn't love clean products that really work! Also I love the packaging, very sleek.

Lovely customer supportGood for gifts 🎁Worth the money 💸Easy subscription management 🔁Fun unboxing 📦Works really well
17 days ago

Love this EG lash serum - works fast, and is super easy to apply. I get compliments all the time and no longer wear mascara on a daily basis. Have even bought this for my friends!

Lovely customer supportHigh qualityInnovative productCool look & feelWorth the money 💸Travel friendly ✈️Works really wellLove the brand's mission 💕
18 days ago

EG is a great product! My lashes has never been so long naturally! Also love that this product is made locally in Toronto 😁


None to provide at this time.

Lovely customer supportGood for gifts 🎁High qualityWorth the money 💸Easy subscription management 🔁Travel friendly ✈️Works really wellAmazing websiteEco-friendly packagingSustainable productsLove the brand's mission 💕
19 days ago