a month ago
Experience
Woof. This was literally a tough cookie. I expected it not to be as great as an Oreo knowing the limitations of no sugar, but i didn’t realize it would make biting into it hurt my teeth!
Useful review?
Sundays
3.47 • 30 Reviews
Sundays makes healthy Oreos with zero sugar, 7g of protein and one net carb.
What is Thingtesting?
Thingtesting is an unbiased place to research and review internet-born brands — because honest reviews help us all shop better. Learn more.
3.5
Average rating from 30 users
63%
Recommend it to a friend
Sundays Reviews
3 months ago
Experience
If i could rate it less than 1 i would. I truly cannot imagine a scenario in which someone would walk away from eating these happy. From the outset, their concept of "healthy" Oreos feels flimsy at best. Per serving, they're about 30 calories less than normal, and it's all due to what must be back-market or surplus chemicals. When I first ate one, I went in with high expectations--they'd worked with just about every CPG and Snack influencer I could think of to get them on my timeline. Then I tasted them. I like to describe them as a hat trick of unfortunate decisions. To start, they taste just like stale Oreo's—you know the taste, more cardboard than cookie, but hey there's probably something sweet coming around the bend. Wrong. The second taste I got can only be described as "oh, so this is why people say they don't like aspartame." I have, historically, never minded a fake taste, but i think that's more because in the past it's been used sparingly or, dare I say it, well. That is not the case here. They taste they like chemicals still wish they were still in the plastic bottle they came from. Then finally, after all that, I figured they couldn't get worse, but thats when the lingering, festering, after taste came. It's like my body didn't want me to forget as a punishment. Or maybe they were just living up to their name "Sundays" and giving me the scaries. Either way, it felt like every cookie left a little mark of negativity that stuck, coated to my mouth, and unwilling to give up the ghost. All in all, it's been my pleasure to let everyone I know not to eat them. It's been a masterclass in branding and something beautiful or expensive doesn't always mean it's better. I promise you, buy the Oreo and put some peanut butter on it if you're that worried about your protein intake. Just don't, don't eat these.
Feedback
I truly don't know what you could do to make these better. Back to the drawing board? Bring in a chef? Convert to a dog food brand?
Useful review?
4 months ago
💰Invested in Sundays
Experience
They really nailed it 🤤
Lovely customer supportWorth the money 💸Tasty 😋
Useful review?
4 months ago
Experience
Insanely good, can't even tell they don't have sugar
Good for gifts 🎁High qualityInnovative productTasty 😋Love the brand's mission 💕
Useful review?
5 days ago
Experience
These are absolutely disgusting. I had to throw all the boxes in the trash. They taste like cardboard with chemicals. Do not buy them!
Useful review?
7 days ago
Experience
Best sugar free cookies I've ever had!
Feedback
Awesome taste, texture, and appearance. Mimics oreos and is what I've been missing for years since I went sugar free years ago. Amazing cookies!
Worth the money 💸
Useful review?
25 days ago
Experience
Our family goes through boxes of these cookies, they are really good. Nice texture, great flavor, not too sweet. My husband is pre-diabetic and these have become his new favorite snack.
Useful review?
a month ago
Experience
I just bought these cookies after seeing an ad and they are the most legit carb conscious/keto thing I've ever had. These are AMAZING. They don't taste exactly like an Oreo but considering the macros they got pretty close. Not sure what all these 1 star reviews are, maybe their tastebuds are broken. My girlfriend and I ate 2 boxes in 3 days.
Useful review?
2 months ago
👀Cookie consumer
Experience
With all due respect to the Sundays team (who undoubtedly directed great efforts in creating this product), the cookies do not achieve the company-described designation of "health conscious" in any meaningful way. Such an outcome is common for attempts at creating healthy sweets. Therefore, consumers who are willing to consume Sundays cookies with their present ingredient mix should simply opt for the familiar taste of marginally less healthy Oreos. Among the contents derailing this product from achieving a healthy status is oat fiber, an insoluble manufactured ingredient that lacks any dietary value because it is fundamentally indigestible. Oat fiber derives from a grain that is typically inundated with pesticides via industrial production processes. Also in the mix is allulose, which in most commercially available forms is synthetically made from corn using genetically modified microbes. Sunflower lecithin, a totally unnecessary additive serving no legitimate purpose in cookie production (and that should at least be organic for the price of a box of Sundays cookies) is also present. Finally, the most ironic addition to the "health conscious" array comes in the form of natural flavors, which are mostly industrially manufactured in labs and production plants where chemical solvents, emulsifiers, flavor modifiers, and preservatives often comprise 80-90% percent of the mixtures. Despite the product backstory, these cookies do not achieve the company-described designation of "health conscious" in any meaningful way, and at nearly $4.2 per ounce, the company is asking consumers to pay equal to or more than they would pay for grass-fed, grass-finished filet mignon or other actually healthy culinary delights. Overall, this product is ideal for the average unthinking Southern California/NYC influencer who claims to "eat healthy" but has never read a book or ingredient list. All due respect to the team again, but any informed health-conscious consumer would reject the product.
Feedback
Either the company website should be modified to reflect the product's non-health conscious status, or the product should be modified to reflect the website's health conscious designation.
Useful review?
2 months ago
Experience
These are almost the perfect cookie. I am so impressed by this brand. Also, the packaging!!! It’s so cute. If you’re looking for a healthy cookie alternative, reach for these. You won’t be disappointed. They even smell like Oreos… it’s wild.
Feedback
I say “almost perfect” because I think they’re a tad expensive.
Innovative productLove the brand's mission 💕
Useful review?