Sundays has permanently closed down.

Sundays reviews and discussion

3.5

63% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Authentic chocolate flavor
  • Crisp cookie texture
  • Abundant cream filling
  • Nostalgic, playful packaging
  • Artificial sweetener aftertaste
  • Grainy, gritty texture
  • Occasional digestive upset
  • Inconsistent oreo parity

Sundays reviews assert that the brand works as a convincing zero-sugar Oreo alternative for many customers, praised for authentic chocolate flavor and crisp texture but criticized for artificial sweeteners, grainy or chalky texture, and occasional stomach upset. This helps buyers: choose Sundays if they need a low-sugar, nostalgic sandwich cookie with solid texture and branding; avoid it if they are sensitive to artificial sweeteners or prefer exact, bakery-like Oreo parity.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

35 reviews and posts

  • I was gifted 6 boxes for the holidays and now they’re all gone! The cookies were a hit at home, at a family friend’s dinner party and at the office. Would buy again! Best tasting zero sugar treat I had in a while

    Feedback

    I was gifted 6 boxes for the holidays and now they’re all gone! The cookies were a hit at home, at a family friend’s dinner party and at the office. Would buy again! Best tasting zero sugar treat I had in a while

  • Tried a box and was quite disappointed. The attempt at an imitation Oreo with no sugar, low carbs, and high protein is not a good combo. These do not taste anywhere near as good as a real Oreo. I just read through several of the 5 star reviews. Don’t want to accuse, but they seem suspect. I’m sorry, but this is my honest review and I’m not able to recommend these cookies to my fiends.

  • Bad taste and cheap ingredients. I don't know how tasters approved of it. Other vendors have done it better before, it's not new or innovative. It's worse than it's competitors, more expensive. This sounds harsh but people need better direction in their "business"

    Feedback

    Change ingredients altogether. Need to be more realistic in your business.

  • These cookies are just…not good. In the same vein that 99% of low calorie “healthy” ice cream tastes off, so do these cookies. I would strongly recommend against buying these.

    Feedback

    It tastes like pure chemicals and artificial sweeteners. Start there

  • These cookies are amazing! From the moment you open these colorful boxes, you embark on a sensory journey. The cookies are absolutely delicious and guilt free! Highly recommend for those who want a fun brand that adults and kids can enjoy, and a delicious tasting product that is not filled with sugar like others out there. I highly recommend you try these amazing cookies as soon as you can!

  • I was literally eating one of these cookies when I discovered that the CEO of the company will contact your employer for leaving a negative review. That’s a disgusting way for a company to behave, and the cookies weren’t even nice - grainy, and weirdly artificially sweet in an unpleasant way. These cookies left a bad taste in my mouth in more ways than one

    Feedback

    Change the sweetness, it’s artificial and cloying

  • I recently tried Sundays cookies that promised to be both healthy and delicious. Unfortunately, I was extremely disappointed with the end result. First and foremost, the taste was incredibly off-putting. Rather than the sweet and indulgent flavor that I was expecting, these cookies tasted overwhelmingly chemical and artificial. It was clear that they were filled with artificial sweeteners and other unhealthy ingredients, despite their claims of being healthy. Additionally, the texture was not at all appealing. The cookies were hard and dense, and seemed to have a chemical aftertaste that lingered in my mouth for hours after eating them. Overall, I would not recommend these cookies. The taste and texture were both subpar, and I feel like I wasted calories on a product that did not live up to its promises. If you're looking for a healthy and delicious cookie, I suggest looking elsewhere.

    Feedback

    Rework the formula, I do believe there's a market for healthier cookie alternatives.

  • The taste and texture reminds me of the knockoff Oreos from the discount section. Unless "sitting open too long" is a flavor, I think they should try again with these. I certainly wouldn't try these again, to say the least.

    Feedback

    Cookies can be dairy-free. Cookies can be vegan. Cookies, at least tasty cookies, cannot be made without a fair amount of sugar, lest they taste like... well, this.

  • Cookies are great! Kids love them (2, 5, 8, 19) as do both parents, one of whom is usually not into low sugar products. There is also a certain level of nostalgia that they have been able to cultivate quite well.

  • Where to start...? Sundays is by far one of the best tasting cookies I have ever had! Knowing that I can eat them with no regrets is awesome. Great product, great team and great health benefits! A healthy take on everyones favorite childhood cookie!

  • Everything from the box to the cookie itself is the best. The branding is iconic and the cookies are delicious!

  • Absolutely excellent experience from first look to last taste! The branding and packaging has such a fun, throwback vibe. The cookie itself is quite unbelievable. As you’re eating and reading the macros at the same time it is hard to comprehend. For me the best is to create my own double stuff and dip that in milk. Next level experience!

  • better than the real thing and no sugar! They have done the impossible :)

  • Sundays are delicious. We love the chocolate flavour and the texture of these cookies.