SmartSweets reviews and discussion

3.9

72% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vivid, nostalgic flavors
  • Lower‑sugar candy formulas
  • Convenient portion packs
  • Vegan, plant‑based options
  • Extremely sticky texture
  • Inconsistent chew quality
  • Notable sweetener aftertaste
  • Potential gi discomfort

SmartSweets earns largely positive reviews as a lower‑sugar candy that satisfies cravings—standouts include Sweet Fish, Peach Rings, Sourmelon Bites, red twists, and gummy worms—while recurring complaints in reviews cite an extremely sticky, tooth‑clinging texture and occasional odd or stevia‑like aftertaste. Reviews also note inconsistent chew across flavors and batches, plus some GI sensitivity for a few users; if you want a healthier candy fix and can accept a different chew, SmartSweets is a compelling swap, but purists may prefer the originals.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,536 reviews and posts

  • I’ve tried many different candies from this brand and while I do think that they’re a close second to their original counterparts, SmartSweets tastes like healthy candy. Personally, I think that some flavors are a hit or miss, but there’s no debate that you get a healthier alternative at an affordable and reasonable price. Hopefully you find a flavor for you.

    Feedback

    Taste! Some candies taste better than others but there’s no denying that there’s so much less sugar in each bite!

  • The peach rings and fake sour patch kids are unreal. Don't feel as guilty eating this candy.

    Feedback

    Price is expensive

  • I mean it is like a gummy but the texture was not as chewy and I wasn’t really a fan of the flavor

    Feedback

    Make it sour

  • Pretty good but some of the types taste a little off

    Feedback

    Quality control

  • Tried smart sweets in an effort to limit my sugars. I was hesitant but they actually taste sweet and help me with my sweet cravings. I like them!

  • honestly, I know it is supposed to have less sugar and be healthier and what not, but it doesn’t taste the best. It has this weird powder on it that kind of shields a taste. I wouldn’t buy it with my own money and probably wouldn’t have anyone else buy it for me. If someone else did buy it for me as a present, I would potentially eat it.

  • I loved the idea of them. The texture of the few I’d tried wasn’t it for me, but I also know how gummy product are made, and appreciate how difficult it is to emulate an artificial candy with clean ingredients. Love the mission, and not giving up as they improve their product formulations!

  • These are really tasty. Do they have the same texture as traditional candy? No. But do they provide a pop of joy with less sugar? You bet.

    Feedback

    More understanding of what their #1 ingredient, IMO, is.

  • I'm addicted to sugar so it is only natural to eat it, but with Smart Sweets I don't have to worry about how much I eat with its low sugar content! The watermelon version are my favourite! Honestly even better than the sugary ones..

    Feedback

    The candies are very chewy to the point they are a bit of work to eat (mostly when you eat a whole package LOL)

  • Meh - this product is just okay for me. I can appreciate the concept of replacing some of your favorite sweets with a healthier option but the taste of these are hit and miss for me depending on which product. I don’t find myself reaching for these products in the store

  • I was really excited to see vegan "healthy" candy more widely available, but this is not worth the price. They would benefit from not trying to be imitations of better products, and the advertised health benefits are not accurate. If you're not vegan, having the non-imitation candies in moderation is honestly going to be better & cost way less.

  • They are very different from the original candies they are trying to imitate in texture and taste. They are low-calorie, but not worth it for the amount of sugar alcohol in them. You are much better off eating the real thing in moderation!

    Feedback

    Would love if brand would stop feeding off of diet culture to make money!

  • It’s a good idea but the texture and flavors are all a little off. A lot of their gummies are too sticky and gum up on your teeth.

    Feedback

    I think the gummies would benefit from a firmer texture

  • LOVE this product. The fish are my favourite treat when I'm craving candy but don't want all the cals!

    Feedback

    More candy options!

  • I discovered this brand while doing some "low carb" days to compliment my workout routine. I needed something sweet and these were recommended (by a blogger I ran across, I think?). I was concerned they'd taste artificial, but they are delicious and definitely satisfy a sweet tooth. My favorite are the sweet and sour (like sour patch kids) ones and the peach rings (so tasty!). You won't miss the sugar.

    Feedback

    These are a great product -- no complaints! However, I have found that some brick & mortar retailers only carry one or two flavors. So, if you find a favorite, remember where you bought them because another retailer might not have the same flavor.

  • They were good! Have a big sweet tooth and they def hit the spot

    Feedback

    A bit gooier and gets stuck in your teeth more than the traditional candy

  • If you want to indulge without the guilt, these are pretty solid.

    Feedback

    The taste is not as great as a full-sugar candy, but they serve their purpose well and I like the single serving packaging.

  • Great alternative for people trying to limit sugar intake. It taste just like the original candy.

  • Very tasty, not as sweet as regular candy

    Feedback

    I wish there was more in the bag, or the bags were smaller.

  • They’re not the greatest low sugar candy. The taste is decent, but they do get stuck to your teeth like glue! The quantity is quite pitiful as well. I’ve had the peach rings and swedish fish and there was no more than a small handful in each bag.

    Feedback

    Very small quantity for the price, texture is very sticky