SmartSweets reviews and discussion

3.9

72% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vivid, nostalgic flavors
  • Lower‑sugar candy formulas
  • Convenient portion packs
  • Vegan, plant‑based options
  • Extremely sticky texture
  • Inconsistent chew quality
  • Notable sweetener aftertaste
  • Potential gi discomfort

SmartSweets earns largely positive reviews as a lower‑sugar candy that satisfies cravings—standouts include Sweet Fish, Peach Rings, Sourmelon Bites, red twists, and gummy worms—while recurring complaints in reviews cite an extremely sticky, tooth‑clinging texture and occasional odd or stevia‑like aftertaste. Reviews also note inconsistent chew across flavors and batches, plus some GI sensitivity for a few users; if you want a healthier candy fix and can accept a different chew, SmartSweets is a compelling swap, but purists may prefer the originals.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,536 reviews and posts

  • I was so surprised to see smart sweets ranked so low on here- I am obsessed! I think you just have to set your expectations, they're candy that only have 3-4 grams of sugar in it. It won't taste identical, but to me it's pretty darn close and I'd rather eat this than the "full sugar" versions anyday. Guilt free!

  • I buy these from Costco and absolutely love them. The Swedish fish are awesome and less sweet than the brand they imitate. I wish they weren’t as expensive in non-Costco stores. I do pick up a slight artificial sweetener aftertaste but I personally don’t mind that.

  • Some of the candies/flavors are better than others! The stevia can have kind of a weird aftertaste in my opinion.

  • This is a good brand/product if you want your sugar fix without actual sugar. however there are still random fillers in this brand, but I really appreciate the low cal low sugar option. good texture and taste imho

    Feedback

    cleaner ingredients

  • Low sugar candies are great to help consumers lower their sugar intake. Sometimes I want something sweet, but candies on the market are often too sweet. These are a great alternative, but there are more options on the market now as well.

    Feedback

    The gummies stuck to my teeth quite a bit...I hope they can improve the texture of the swedish fish and peach rings!

  • Love these, taste great, can give you gas if you're sensitive to chicory root fiber.

  • This brand is the closest to candy i’ve ever had for not being really candy, but the artificial sugar taste is pretty strong. And it’s pretty pricey.

    Feedback

    The ones like swedish fish are super sticky and get stuck in my teeth.

  • These sweets claim to be a low sugar better for you alternative to nostalgic candies and it does so with a few compromises. The texture of these candies especially the gummies lack the bouncy type of jelly texture that the originals have and trades it for something a lot more firm and set in. Considering the huge difference in sugar content and the added fiber, I think it's a good item to curb bad sugar habits and functions exceptionally in that mode.

  • Great that these are a "healthy" option, but the flavor and texture is quite bad.

    Feedback

    Should be reformulated to attempt to improve the texture and taste. These are barely palatable.

  • I thought the candies would taste a little better but the packaging is cute.

    Feedback

    The flavors of the candy are not as realistic as they advertise. The taste could be a lot better.

  • I really wanted to love these as gummies are my favorite candy. However, I haven't found any of the flavors overly enjoyable.

    Feedback

    I found the texture of these items to be very strange and sticky. The sweeteners are overly sweet and leave a strange aftertaste in my mouth.

  • At first bite they taste feel like “normal” candy. I did notice after a few they are more gummy than other candies.

    Feedback

    Texture could use improvement.

  • I had the gummy people's didn't quite enjoy the texture. kept sticking to my teeth, but the flavor were on point.

    Feedback

    If we could just figure out sticking to teeth part.

  • These are really tasty! I love how they taste like the actual candy, but they fill you up way faster. I can eat half a bag and save the rest for later and still fill my sweet tooth.

    Feedback

    resealable bags!

  • Smart sweets are pretty effective for healthier sweets. I feel they don’t differ from any other candies and are tasty for gatherings finger foods

    Feedback

    More healthier ingredients

  • Great alternative to some of the common sweets.

    Feedback

    Flavor is alright, sometimes a bit chalky

  • I think it’s small for the price and tastes very artificial.

    Feedback

    I don’t think the product needs improvement, I just don’t think it was for me.

  • Smart sweets are a great alternative for regular candy. They won’t taste exactly as the candy they mirror but if you are open minded then they will be your new go to! Plus packed with fiber!!

    Feedback

    The candy sticks to your teeth but not sure that can be avoided.

  • I love these candies—they make it fun to eat low-sugar. Their Peach Rings and Watermelon Slices are definitely my favorite. I just wish they were a little more affordable.

  • These are great low-sugar treats! I have been tying to eat higher protein/lower sugar for years, and find these to be a great option when I'm in the mood for something sweet. I appreciate the variety offered as well.