Thingtesting Logo

Magnolia Bakery

4.5 • 93 Reviews

Magnolia Bakery sells a range of baked goods featuring their famous banana pudding.

magnoliabakery.comArrow up right
Shop
Reward
7% reward
Magnolia Bakery Reviews

Best of Thingtesting4.5

Magnolia Bakery earns glowing reviews for delivering lush, ultra‑creamy Banana Pudding—often called the best and a consistent, must‑visit classic—while feedback on other items is mixed. Reviewers praise decadent textures, fun monthly pudding specials, and reliable in‑store consistency, but note weaknesses such as occasionally dry cupcakes and cakes, overly sweet flavors, lack of vegan options, and shipped or non‑NYC pudding tasting less fresh.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

Photos

Rewards
Shop
Review
Reward
7% reward

Join to earn a 7% reward

Join Thingtesting to earn a cash-based commission when you shop and review Magnolia Bakery using our link.

By continuing, you agree to Thingtesting’s Terms of Service, Community Guidelines, and the use of data in the Privacy Policy

Articles

Reviews and Posts

View all 93

  • 1mo ago

    I think everything that I've had from here has been delicious. I love their banana pudding. In January 2020, they released a special edition pink banana pudding, that I was obsessed with. I think they should make it a regular option on the menu!

  • 9mo ago

    Yes, magnolia bakery does live up to the hype. Their cult-favorite banana pudding is the perfect balance of fake and real banana flavor (gotta have that artificial banana in there to be a good banana dessert, imo!). Will definitely visit again next time I’m near a location.

  • 1y ago

    The banana pudding cookies are good. Nothing beats a homemade cookie, but I like these for enough to purchase occasionally when I don't have time to bake. The texture is soft. Not too sugary. Some packaged cookies are really sweet and these are ok.

  • 3y ago

    Oh goodness Magnolia Bakery is sinful. Yes, they have amazing banana pudding, but they've also crept into Costco as of last week and have a box of 18 individually wrapped soft baked cookies - "Banana Pudding Cookies" -in classic vanilla with white chocolate chips and confetti- with white chocolate chips. You want these. If not by themselves, they make an incredible base for a scoop of vanilla icecream!!

View all 93 reviews

Alternatives

What is Magnolia Bakery?

Magnolia Bakery sells a range of baked goods featuring their famous banana pudding.