Magnolia Bakery sells a range of baked goods featuring their famous banana pudding.

Magnolia Bakery is highly praised for its delicious, creamy, and unmatched banana pudding and decadent cupcakes, which are considered as its primary strengths. However, its weaknesses include relatively high prices and some items being overly sweet, as well as inconsistent quality on certain items beyond the banana pudding, which some customers find underwhelming.

Magnolia Bakery

lemon bar

Banana pudding

Cupcakes

Cake

Brownies

Bakery

Their desserts are good and iconic, but too rich for my blood. I will say that their consistency is impressive - you never catch the cakes or the banana pudding on an off day, they always taste exactly the same, and that's very impressive. 

Got the mini cheesecakes for a friend’s birthday and it was a hit! Will continue to do that for other people’s birthdays. So so delicious!

When I tell you I am in love with the banana pudding… WOW it is so amazing and worth trying!! I wish I lived closer to NYC💕💕

The Banana Pudding is by no means overrated. The Lemon Bars are extremely underrated and I used to bring them across the Pacific when visiting a friend, because she loved them that much.

I had their banana pudding in New York and wow it was so yummy. Very tasty and filling for the small cup. 

Best banana pudding I have ever had! Their monthly specials are so fun!

Magnolia is an amazing bakery. Their cupcakes are moist with flavorful, not too sweet, buttercream frosting. The most noteworthy item is their banana pudding. It is creamy and delicious. 

who doesn't love a bakery that sells slices of cakes. Magnolia Bakery is a NYC classic and a go to for all birthday needs.

Magnolia Bakery

Similar brands

Best of