Start a review
Magnolia Bakery
3.67 • 3 Reviews
Magnolia Bakery sells a range of baked goods featuring their famous banana pudding.
What is Thingtesting?
Thingtesting is an unbiased place to research and review internet-born brands — because honest reviews help us all shop better. Learn more.
3.7
Average rating from 3 users
Magnolia Bakery Reviews
3 months ago
Experience
Dreamy banana pudding; everything else is more basic but still delicious. The banana pudding flavor changes every month, so you can never get bored of it. It's light and fluffy. The best and most consistent thing about Magnolia Bakery is its ratios. From icing on cakes to amount of banana in the pudding, they know how to give each element its own space.
Feedback
Going to the store itself is an experience that you shouldn't miss out on. I also recommend checking out the cookbooks!
Good for gifts 🎁High qualityCool look & feel
Useful review?
3 months ago
Experience
The iconic Magnolia Bakery! Even if you're not a fan of bananas, pudding, or banana pudding definitely worth trying one time for the one time.
Feedback
Make your banana pudding more accessible by wholesaling at Whole Foods, Target, etc.!
Good for gifts 🎁High qualityWorth the money 💸
Useful review?
3 months ago
Experience
As someone who cannot stand bananas, I unfortunately cannot review the banana pudding— but so many people love it that I’m sure millions of people can review it for me. The chocolate chip cookies are delicious, but not, to me, worth the price; trying one instantly reminded me of that Pulp Fiction scene with the milkshake. Definitely a great place to visit for a little classic NYC tourist moment, but not necessarily a staple for me.
Good for gifts 🎁
Useful review?