Start a review
Average rating from 68 users
88%Recommend to a friend
Magnolia Bakery Reviews
The banana pudding is among the best I've tried. It's super light and far more airy than most. While the classic banana is my go-to, the seasonal flavors make it fun to visit Magnolia at different times throughout the year. The cupcakes are also delicious and aesthetic with different pastel-colored varieties. Perfect for a gift.
Their desserts are good and iconic, but too rich for my blood. I will say that their consistency is impressive - you never catch the cakes or the banana pudding on an off day, they always taste exactly the same, and that's very impressive.
Gluten free banana pudding omg
What is Thingtesting?
Thingtesting is an unbiased place to research and review internet-born brands — because honest reviews help us all shop better. Learn more.
Best banana pudding ever! YUM
The banana pudding is the best banana pudding you'll get, but everything else is okay, and a bit too sweet.
I tried Magnolia Bakery for the first time during my last trip to NYC. Their banana pudding was delicious, but I found their other items, like their coffee and muffins, to be underwhelming. It's also quite expensive, but that just might be due to its location.
love the banana pudding - flavor is unmatched
Their banana pudding is known for a reason! I did try their seasonal pumpkin spice banana pudding and really preferred the original, although I'm also not a fan of Starbucks pumpkin spice lattes.
Delish banana pudding. Ridiculously overpriced.
had their banana pudding earlier this year when i visited nyc and my mind was BLOWN. they're hyped up for a reason. sooo delicious and i wish i lived near a location bc i would be going there 24/7