Madewell
4.4
Madewell earns strong reviews as a reliable source for well‑made jeans and durable basics, with many praising consistent fits (including petite and multiple lengths), easy‑care fabrics, and long‑lasting wardrobe staples. Reviews also flag weaknesses—hit‑or‑miss quality in non‑denim categories (especially jewelry and some basics), occasional awkward sizing, and even squeaky leather flats—making the brand effective for denim and leather accessories but less consistent elsewhere.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
Ask questions or start a discussion
Shop Madewell
About
This page has not yet been
Photos
Join to earn a 15% reward
Join Thingtesting to earn a cash-based commission when you shop and review Madewell using our link.
Articles
Reviews and Posts
View all 18
Madewell is solid for basics. I just bought the triple metal keeper leather belt. I was hoping it would be a bit wider, but I really like the quality - it truly beats out the quality of some of my designer belts (that rhyme with “Rottega Reneta”). I think it’s a great place to buy well-made (no pun intended) handbags and belts.
Verified purchase
4mo ago
loving the latest pieces madewell has been putting out, from their leather and suede bags to shirts and dresses, balancing quality and price. their jeans have always been a favorite, stretchy yet fitting just right. looking forward to what's next for spring.
2mo ago
Madewell lives up to the name. Most everything I’ve gotten from there is made well. I’m careful to check fabric content prior to purchase, but this is a great spot for nice (boring) basics. You aren’t going to blow anyone away with your style prowess, but I’ve never been disappointed. My only complaint is that the shoes fart when you walk, but I’ve found a lot of leather flats do until they soften up.
Verified purchase
6mo ago
Honestly, most of my wardrobe is from Madewell, especially my jeans. It’s one of the only places where I can consistently find pants that actually fit me well—especially since I need petite sizing. I can always count on them for elevated basics and pieces that really last. I’ve only ever had one pair of jeans develop a hole a few months after buying them, and when I brought them into the store, they took them back with no questions asked and sent me a new pair. Such great customer service. I also have a whole drawer full of their t-shirts that I’ve worn for many seasons and countless washes, and they still look great. Definitely a go-to brand for me.
Verified purchase
Alternatives
What is Madewell?
Madewell makes stylish clothing, bags, and accessories.
In their own words
At Madewell, good days start with great jeans. Shop our entire collection of denim, clothing, shoes, bags and accessories for Women and Men. Madewell
This page has not been
Socials
