Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

4.7

95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Velvety, ultra-creamy texture
  • Inventive, distinctive flavors
  • Plentiful, well-distributed mix-ins
  • Impressive dairy-free options
  • Inconsistent flavor execution
  • Occasionally icy, grainy texture
  • Some flavors overly sweet
  • Variable creaminess across pints

Jeni's Ice Creams earns rapturous reviews for rich, ultra‑creamy texture and inventive, true‑to‑label flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, confirming the brand is excellent. Reviews also flag downsides: pints are expensive, quality varies by flavor, and some report iciness or overly sweet/salty notes and occasional freezer burn from stores.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,842 reviews and posts

  • Love the brown butter almond brittle and that Whole Foods Carrie’s the brand

    Feedback

    Expensive price point

  • SO GOOD!! The birthday cake flavor is a weekly purchase and is so worth the price

    Feedback

    NA

  • Jeni’s ice cream is good, however, I can’t get behind their business practices. I had a friend who finally achieved her dream of opening a brick and mortar ice cream shop, and Jeni‘s ice cream intentionally opened a place across the street from her ice cream shop. This company intentionally tries to drive out the business of other small and local ice cream shops in the area and it’s some thing I can’t get behind.

    Feedback

    Stay in your lane

  • Amazing flavors, great quality. Visiting the shops is always a nice treat.

  • I dream of Brambleberry Crisp. IDK how they do it. Every flavor combination is amazing, even the off-the-wall stuff. Shipping/Packaging for website-orders was very solid and my ice cream didn't melt at all in the summer (I typically buy from grocery store, but will occasionally put in an order online to get some of the new flavors that might not make it to my local store)

    Feedback

    N/A

  • Delicious!!! Amazing variety of flavors, from classic to innovative. I loooove their Gooey Butter Cake, and have never had ice cream that got cake chunks right before. Even if I'm not a huge fan of a flavor, I'll still finish the pint because it's just that good.

    Feedback

    Nothing :)

  • Amazing flavors and great quality ice cream

    Feedback

    Prices are extremely high, maybe offer quart sizes if the product to offset the cost

  • I love Jeni's! They've got really delicious and innovative flavors. It's on the pricier side, but makes for a great treat on special occasions.

  • My favorite ice cream brand hands down, it's the right balance of sweet and creamy. I love their peach shortcake ice cream and their pineapple upside down cake one

  • I am a loud and proud supporter of Jeni's Splendid Ice Cream. It's hard to find premium ice creams made without stabilizers or emulsifiers but are still creamy with egg yolk-y richness. I love ice cream without additives. Jeni's fits the description and their range of flavors make them so fun to try and experiment with. My favorites so far include Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, Brown Butter Almond Brittle, and Buttercream Birthday Cake.

    Feedback

    Price point could be a little more affordable.

  • If you can go to a Jeni's scoop shop, the experience is amazing. Their waffle cones are phenomenal and it's great to be able to sample the flavors--my favorite is the ooey gooey cake. However, their pints in grocery stores just don't measure up, and the experience just isn't the same.

    Feedback

    Their pints in grocery stores just don't measure up to how the ice cream tastes in scoop shops, and the experience just isn't the same.

  • I have a Jeni's in my neighborhood and the ice cream is so good. I have never bought ice cream from them online.

  • These are amazing. Delicious everyt time. Love the Bramblerry crisp the most!

  • I have been to Jeni's Ice Cream stores and have also purchased ice cream from grocery stores. Jeni's Ice Cream Stores: The employees are always welcoming. The stores use small metal spoons for the samples. They encourage sampling the flavors. My go to order is Brambleberry Crisp with Brown Butter Almond Brittle. They make fresh waffle cones. Jeni's Ice Cream: I love their packaging it colorful and fun. My favorite flavor is brambleberry crisp.

  • I love Jeni's ice creams! As I tend to prefer fruit-based desserts, I don't always have a ton of options but their Brambleberry Crisp flavor is one of my favorite ice creams of all time. Topping my list of all-time favorite ice cream flavors, however, was their Wildberry Lavender, which they have tragically discontinued. Jeni, if you are reading this, I would do anything to have it back!

  • So good! Got sent a box as a gift and it was well packaged.

    Feedback

    Broader availability

  • Received a big box of these with 6 flavors from a client for Christmas. Really delicious and high quality ice-cream. They're not overly unique but have a nice balance of simple and intriguing. Especially enjoyed the strawberry oats, which is on the sweeter side, as well as the dark chocolate ice cream, which is on the less sweeter side. Since I wasn't the one who brought these, I can't speak to the shipping times, but it was well packaged and arrived frozen solid.

    Feedback

    None really, but if I was being really picky, perhaps some more lower-calorie options could be nice as well.

  • Jeni's ice cream is so creamy and delicious. Flavors that I'd be scared to try just from the name are surprisingly delicious! I'll eat any of their stuff that has fruit and cake in it and I'm a huge fan of their cookies and cream! I like that they have non milk options that taste equally as good.

  • Luscious texture, delicious flavors, creamy mouthfeel - everything you want in an ice cream! THE BEST!

    Feedback

    Would love to see Jeni's venture into more tropical fruit & Asian ingredients.