Ithaca Hummus reviews and discussion

4.5

91% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vibrant, zesty flavor profiles
  • Creamy, thick hummus texture
  • Clean, preservative‑free ingredients
  • Inventive, collaborative flavor lineup
  • Occasionally overpowering lemon tang
  • Inconsistent, sometimes grainy texture
  • Small, modest container size
  • Seasoning intensity varies widely

Ithaca Hummus earns enthusiastic reviews for vibrant, fresh flavors and a smooth, thick texture that elevates staples like Lemon Dill, Lemon Garlic, Everything Bagel, French Onion, and Black Bean, signaling the brand is very good. Reviewers praise the clean, preservative‑free ingredients and creative collaborations, but note drawbacks including a higher price, occasional overly lemony or strong seasoning, inconsistent texture (too thick, grainy, or thin for some), and small container sizes.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

96 reviews and posts

  • Ithaca hummus is amazing. I'm really picky with my hummus, and usually I'll buy it and never finish the tub because I get sick of the taste and texture. I don't think I've ever not finished a tub of ithaca hummus! I love the beet flavour, but honestly you cannot really go wrong with any of the flavours.

    Feedback

    A little pricey, and hard to find.

  • One of the best pre-packaged hummus brands on the market. The Lemon Dill is exceptional.

  • I'm a big fan of their hummus, especially the lemon dill and lemon garlic flavors! They have a nice fresh taste and are more flavorful than most other brands I've bought in stores. The only flavor I don't enjoy is the buffalo ranch - I feel like it doesn't taste like hummus anymore since the flavors are quite strong.

  • Ithaca Hummus makes their product with only real and tasty ingredients. I have tried a few different flavors like lemon dill, kalamata olive and lemon garlic. They're all very tasty. I like the versatility of their flavors as I can choose to consume them with different snacks like chips or crackers, etc. They make a great side dip or spread.

    Consumer
  • Fresh fresh fresh. Great selection of flavors. Unique flavors other brands don't offer.

  • Incredibly rich and tangy hummus. A little goes a long way. Love this with fresh veggies or slices of warm baguette.

  • best hummus, great flavors, I always make sure I have this in stock when I'm having guests.

  • After trying several different flavors/brands of hummus, this is hands down the best. The lemon garlic and the everything bagel are my two favorite flavors.

  • I generally make my own hummus but Ithaca hummus is a brand I trust the flavor of and will buy at the store. I really like the variety of flavors and the product has a good texture!

  • My favorite hummus out there. Its so delicious and has such a fun variety of flavors!

  • In love with the lemon dill flavor! I always have it stocked in my fridge.

  • Delicious, smooth, strong flavours

    Feedback

    More to a carton

  • Really tasty. Has a super fresh, homemade vibe in the best way. Tastes less manufactured than so many other brands. Also nice acid and flavors are fun.

  • Obsessed with the lemon garlic hummus

  • Ithaca is not my favorite hummus. I find it grainy - but some do like that texture

    Feedback

    It’s good in a pinch but I have other hummuses I would prefer