4
85% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
HighKey
4.0 • 52 Reviews
•
HighKey reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Addictive chocolate chip flavor
- Buttery mini cookie texture
- Keto‑friendly ingredient profile
- Portable grab‑and‑go convenience
- Grainy cookie mouthfeel
- Oily aftertaste presence
- Crumbly cookie texture
- Noticeable sweetener aftertaste
HighKey reviews show the brand works as a satisfying low‑carb cookie alternative: reviewers praise chocolate chip and mini cookies for their addictive, buttery crunch and keto‑friendly profile but repeatedly note off‑putting textures and sweetener aftertastes. Strengths include flavor variety and grab‑and‑go convenience; weaknesses center on grainy or oily mouthfeel, crumbly texture, and noticeable sweetener finish—helpful for buyers deciding between taste, texture, and dietary needs.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
52 reviews and posts
I’ve tried two different flavors of HighKey cookies. The gingerbread/molasses flavor was good, but nothing special. It just didn’t have the right taste to it. The chocolate chip cookies on the other hand are down right addictive. Once you eat one, you can’t stop. They’re so yummy! A great healthier alternative to the traditional chocolate chip cookie.
Feedback
I would like to see this brand offered in more stores.
Crunchy yummy treats. My boyfriend wasn’t a fan of the lemon ones I got him, but I don’t typically like lemon desserts and I enjoyed them. I feel like they had a slight aftertaste related to the sweetener, which I believe is monk fruit, but it’s better than many other similar items I’ve tried.
Loved the concept of it all, loved how soft and bite sized they were. They initially tasted good but left a weird after taste
Feedback
Maybe the coconut oil that left a weird taste or film on the top of my mouth
StoreI enjoyed this bag of chocolate cookies, seemed like a healthier choice. Quality is great just a little grainy, might get crumble pieces but so addicting!
Feedback
The pricing is a little high, wish the bag contained more for the price. I did try these at an airport so the price was exaggerated!
Influencer for HighKeyTasted these even though I’m not suppose to eat chocolate but I liked the snack. It’s low carb and I like that
Feedback
I would definitely share the brand especially with people that I know want low carbs and a good snack.
4y ago
These products generally taste like normal snacks, and I appreciate that they are low/no-carb and all, however I believe that there should be more accessible information about the ingredients and their effects.
Feedback
Just because some thing is low/no-carb, doesn’t mean it’s immediately okay for you to gorge yourself on them. I think “keto” snacks as a whole need to improve their communication about their ingredients, their purpose, and the education around nutrition. These snacks are like diet food and can encourage disordered eating behaviors without the proper education.
3y ago
I have tried many of their products and live just about every single one!
Feedback
All of their products are great keto friendly options
3y ago
Their mini chocolate chip cookies are really good, especially to be keto. I normally prefer soft cookies, but these crispy ones were enjoyable nonetheless.
Feedback
More variety. Offer soft cookies too.
3y ago
SOO YUMMMY
Feedback
They are great, add more in the bag 😉
3y ago
I got the chocolate chip mini cookies from Costco. I have a sweet tooth so I'm always on the hunt for delicious treats with 0 sugar. These are great!
3y ago
Delicious snack and super buttery (makes sense because they're keto)!
3y ago
I love HighKey cookies because indulge in something sweet without the guilt that you typically experience with any other cookie brand.