Good Weird reviews and discussion

I wanted to love this but it's a no for me. Packaging looks cute but feels super cheap. I love the idea of the cooling tip but it does not work with the consistency of this eye cream. I am unable to properly blend in the product with the cooling tip and always have to use my fingers to pat in. As for consistency of the eye cream, the first couple uses it was a bit gritty which was weird, now it's smooth but so thick that it takes a lot of patting to absorb and blend into the skin. I found the color confusing it looked almost like it was tinted to cover dark circles but that was not mentioned as a product benefit. I do not have dark circles but I do have dry skin and unfortunately after 2 months of use I have seen no improvements in hydration under my eyes.

I got the Cold Brew Undereye cream as part of a Thingdrop and while I love the branding and mission of Good Weird, this product felt like just another skincare/beauty product that doesn't do much. I used it everyday for three weeks and didn't see a visible difference in my skin. On days that I didn't use it, I actually noticed the area under my eyes was extra dry.

My results have been really good. It's definitely one of the most effective caffeine eye creams I have used for trying to reduce swollen bags in the morning and before Zoom calls. Rolls on easily via their little built-in aluminum applicator and it disappears quickly after going on white so you can see where it's applied.

great product and feels nice

The product is… fine, I didn’t really notice much impact although I’m sure it takes time for this to be visible. But I felt no joy or calm or whatever when I was applying it (it doesn’t smell like anything and isn’t a particularly luxe consistency). I found the tube/applicator to be really annoying and had to take a needle to poke it before any product would come out. Before doing that I thought it was straight up defective.

It’s probably the smoothest under eye product I’ve applied, but I have yet to see results that make me think it’s the best under eye product I’ve used.

I think this works...either way it feels great putting it on.

I like the packaging, the ingredients. Quick shipping. I have the caffeine eye cream. The applicator feels great (cool) and I like the slight tint to it. Time will tell if it's really any different than other caffeine eye creams, but I do like it.

I have extremely sensitive skin/eyes and have never found an eye cream that doesn't irritate me - until this! Honestly I was astonished. I can't yet speak to the results that the brand claims it will make, but I can say it's a non-irritating, nourishing eye cream. I also love the packaging.

This is a really nice eye cream! Feels really nourishing to the skin, but not so rich that you're worried about it causing milia. It seems to also play well with makeup on top, but you definitely want to make sure it's dried down a bit before applying a concealer. My one issue with the product is unfortunately the cooling, doe foot applicator. It feels really nice and cool as you apply the eye cream! But it just does not do the job of rubbing the eye cream in, it just kind of spreads it out. So now I pat the cream on with my finger and then run the cooling applicator over top of it for that nice cool feel.

ive tried the bronzer, which I love, but wish the pump was better and didn't squeeze out so much. especially since I got a darker color. the packing was so cute and unboxing was great as well. I love that its unisex

I LOVE this product (Cold Brew Undereye) so much!!! My under eye area is very sensitive and every product has either irritated my skin or straight up burned when applied. This product has been the only exception and its metal applicator is sooooo good for early mornings. I endlessly recommend this to anyone and everyone!

Fine product - definitely brightens my under eyes when used but haven't seen a lasting difference and occasionally leaves a bit of a residue. Definitely worth the purchase due to the discount, but not sure I'd seek it out to re-buy.

Love the packaging and cooling tip of the eye cream. In terms of the formula, its slightly hydrating so good for the daytime, but I don't think it'll provide long-term results for dark circles or fine lines.

I’m usually not an eye cream person but at the price I figured I’d try it. I love the metal applicator, it helps depuff and wakes me up in the morning. The eye cream helps cover up dark circles and overall is something I’d repurchase

Really enjoying this eye cream. The metal applicator is always a big plus for an eye product. The cream itself is gentle and doesn't irritate my eyes, which happens to me often with eye products. I also love the slight tint to it.

product packaging is nice as is the applicator but as far as eye creams go it's just okay. I don't see it doing much as I have used a few other eye creams and like better / have seen better results with. I do love what the company stands for the and cute packaging it came in but don't think I'd repurchase.

I feel like this has been helping to hide the circles under my eyes in the morning. It’s lightly tinted enough to add some concealment without being too dark. I use my finger instead of applying directly, so i don’t have issues with the applicator. It does remain visible after my initial application, but once I apply my tinted moisturizer, it all blends nicely. No complaints!

It didn’t make any noticeable difference but should it? It didn’t irritate and it did hydrate. It blended well (with finger/not applicator) and created a nice base layer for whatever sunscreen or makeup you put on top. It didn’t make my eyes look different, more awake or younger. That said a reliable non-irritating eye cream is a good thing.

I like the metal applicator. The formula is moisturizing but I’m not sure if it is doing much for dark circles and fine lines. I would need to test if for a few months to see those results.