Everlane reviews and discussion

4.1

84% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Durable cashmere sweaters
  • Flattering cheeky denim
  • Minimalist timeless designs
  • Soft comfortable fabrics
  • Inconsistent sizing across styles
  • Boxy unflattering silhouettes
  • Thin sheer cotton tees
  • Occasional quality fluctuations

Everlane earns largely positive reviews for durable, minimalist basics—especially cashmere sweaters, Way-High and 90s/Classic Cheeky jeans, alpaca knits, and sturdy backpacks—suggesting the brand is good for timeless wardrobe staples. Reviews also flag real drawbacks: inconsistent and often boxy fits, variable and sometimes declining quality in cotton tees and newer drops, limited size inclusivity/lengths, and controversies around sustainability claims and union-busting.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

751 reviews and posts

  • I've ordered several garments from Everlane. The majority of items are well made basics. I try to shop from sustainable and transparent brands and Everlane definitely hits those criteria.

  • Everlane is tried and true for basics. I found their quality to be better in the early days than now but I still go to them for my t-shirts, which are always well cut and well priced. I'm less enthused about their sweaters and other items in recent years.

    Feedback

    If you're looking for basics at an affordable price, Everlane is great.

  • Best button down shirts for women. Hands down. Don't sleep on their cotton - it's crisp and the perfect weight.

  • the OG elevated basics brand is nothing extraordinary, but no flops so far. it's hard to blind-buy given the general boxiness of the silhouettes and different pant rises. i've only bought everlane pants from nordstrom because of their free return policy. the price point isn't the most accessible, but you can find NWT items at steep markdown on therealreal at times.

  • I love the aesthetic of Everlane, and as a brand, they really hooked me. I've gotten one item from them, a black turtleneck that I still wear often to this day. But to be honest, I don't really get that "high quality" feel from it. I don't think it's worth the expense - maybe I just got the wrong product? But I think you could spend the same amount of money somewhere else and get a longer lasting item.

  • I got two pairs of Everlane jeans recently- the quality of the product is very good at a good price point for the fabric content

    Feedback

    I would love to see less plastic in the packaging, and no short version of the pants was limiting. I did have them tailored though, which was worth it.

  • Love their clothing. Timeless pieces that can be worn forever. Great shipping and wonderful customer service.

  • My favorite grey sweater was from Everlane, but it got so worn out because I wore it so much

  • Purchased their best selling pant (Way High Drape Pant) and am VERY impressed with the quality. While the price point leaves a bit to be desired (especially in Canada) I would definitely purchase another pair.

  • Big fan, huge. I like the simplicity of Everlane's clothing, very good basics and classics to help keep your wardrobe modern and fun.

    Feedback

    Free returns. With how much we spend on the items themselves it would be great to have free returns and no re-shelving fee. Additionally, I purchased a long sleeve shirt from y'all a year or two ago and it has a hole in it, keep in mind I didnt do anything super risky in this shirt. I wasnt rolling around in rose bushes or getting hooked on loose nails.

  • Their clothes look good but are on the pricey side, although I appreciate the transparency behind their products. As for the quality, I feel it is the same as Muji - which is good, but I am expecting more from a "high-quality" brand.

  • Casual pieces, very SF look. Quality not always the highest, but medium quality for medium prices makes sense.

  • As an early day Everlane customer, I feel the quality has slipped over the years. Not surprising as the brand has expanded its product line to full set of products, but some of the "early day" items like Made in LA t-shirts and reverse denim bags are surely missed.

    Feedback

    With a brand advocating for radical transparency and workers rights, why did they move some clothing production out of the US? Those Made in LA t shirts were fantastic and fit with the brand ethos.

  • High quality basic t-shirts. I wear them daily to work for a business casual look. They wash well and do not loose their shape.

  • Love the design. Good quality basics

    Feedback

    Pricing has increased dramatically over the years. Sizing needs some serious work, both in consistency AND availability (going up to size 16 for SOME items is hardly enough range to classify your brand as "inclusive"). Also they union bust

  • Everlane jeans are some of the most comfortable and flattering jeans I own. Their basics are also excellent quality.

  • I have purchase pants, pima cotton stretch shirts in different styles and Everlane underwear. I love all the products at first but they wear down really quickly. Everything gets holes or rips. It’s sad because for the price point it should be higher quality.

    Feedback

    Higher quality and more durable fabric.

  • Most of their stuff is overhyped and low quality. The cashmere is nice and cheap though!

  • I have a pair of white shorts from Everlane that are perfect. Will definitely look to them again for bottoms. Really great quality and fit.

  • Love the styles available.

    Feedback

    T-Shirts have held up pretty well, but I've purchased better quality for less elsewhere. The pants also fit small.