Everlane reviews and discussion

4.1

84% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Durable denim construction
  • Soft, luxurious cashmere
  • Minimalist, timeless aesthetics
  • Comfortable everyday pants
  • Inconsistent sizing accuracy
  • Boxy, unflattering silhouettes
  • Thin, shrink‑prone cotton tees
  • Narrow, blister‑prone footwear

Everlane proves a reliable source for well-made basics, according to reviews of Everlane, with standouts like Way‑High Jeans, Classic/Cheeky denim, cashmere, alpaca sweaters, and utility/barrel pants that hold up and anchor capsule wardrobes. Reviews also fault inconsistent sizing and boxy, unflattering cuts, variable fabric quality (thin tees, shrinking/pilling), and a drift from earlier simplicity—plus ethics concerns (union-busting) and limited size inclusivity—making the brand hit-or-miss depending on the piece.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

752 reviews and posts

  • Products are hit or miss, but I love the cashmere sweaters. Super well priced.

  • I bought a sweater from Everlane and it has become my most favorite sweater. I wear it all the time and the quality is impeccable. Love the shops, the brand and everything about Everlane!

  • their style is almost TOO basic, but priced a bit more expensive than true basics like UNIQLO.

  • The clothes are very minimalistic you don't see anything too flashy it's mostly the color that changes. Some items don't feel like it should for it's price which can be upsetting.

    Feedback

    I think they need to source other materials for some clothing items since they don't feel as high quality

  • Listen. I'm a sucker for their copy. The products seem to vary, though—in size, in shape, in comfort. Love them, but I (a petite person) have to return items more often than I'd like to.

    Feedback

    Generally awesome. Great marketing. Great mission. Inconsistent sizing and comfort.

  • I bought a pair of black mom jeans and a 3-pack set of COVID face masks from them and was genuinely surprised by this brand! At the time of purchase, I felt like I was splurging a little and wasn't having toooo high of expectations on how the products will turn out but I'm shocked because the quality has SO AMAZING! The jeans have been my go-to pair for the past 2 years!!!! and the face masks literally got me through the entire pandemic - I used to throw them in the wash after 0.5 seconds of use and they never faded and tore. I'm only left with one today because I lost the other two but it still lives in my bag on the off-chance that I might need a mask somewhere. Honestly, both the products fit so well and the quality was amazing. The fact that I bought a pair of jeans online and they fit perfectly says a lot, so overall I'm very impressed and highly recommend!

    Feedback

    The shipping did take a while to arrive, but I ordered to Australia - in the middle of the pandemic. So, can I really blame them?

  • I wanted to like Everyone, I really did. However, after just one wash, the t-shirts shrunk substantially. They also wrinkle very easily. Other shirts I have, after years of washing, have not shrunk and come out of the dryer wrinkle-free.

    Feedback

    higher quality fabrics

  • Love every product I have purchased both online and in stores! I really appreciate the transparent pricing on the website, when making decisions on pieces I want to invest in!

    Feedback

    Sizing is always off. Sometimes I can be a 4, 6, or 8. I have pants that run from size 26 to 29. I almost always a 27/28. Before purchasing I really rely on the reviews for sizing or contact customer support. I tend to return/exchange a lot just based on the sizing of it.

  • My style is pretty simple, so I really appreciate the focus on basics. The clothes are relatively comfortable, and I appreciate the focus on using sustainable practices and materials. The website is quite easy to use, and Everlane is probably one of the only brands I enjoy shopping for.

    Feedback

    I don't have a great reference point for this, but I don't always feel like the clothes are the most durable. Perhaps all jeans eventually get holes?

  • All of my Everlane clothes feel so incredibly well-made and luxurious. I look forward to winter specifically so I can wear my Everlane sweaters. It is definitely pricey, but you are paying for high quality clothes that will last you for years.

  • Great clothing styles for a minimal look especially if you are in your 30's and can't figure out where to shop anymore. Sweaters are great quality. Pay close attention to washing instructions for garments as I made the mistake of putting a dry clean only sweater in the wash and dryer. I also found a shirt I had missed out on last year on Poshmark brand new and its great. Have tried their jeans but I am short and they were way too long.

  • High quality, and reliable for basics. Worth noting the price for those on a budget and the difficulty of exchanging/looking for things in person.

  • I love the quality of Everlane products. There are some things that I'm not in love with but that doesn't hinder me from purchasing.

    Feedback

    Sizing can be better.

  • I've always loved the quality of what I purchase from Everlane. It's not the most "fun" brand, or where I go to find clothing for a special occasion, but it's perfect for basics and work. Fair prices and I like the brand mission.

  • I really like this brand and think they have great products!

    Feedback

    I can struggle with the sizing to have the correct waist size but they have been fixing this with their jeans in the past couple years. Sometimes the fits are all too boxy, but that can be great when it is what I am going for. The size 11 shoes are always running too small so I can't shop their shoe section.

  • Simple functional styles using good materials

    Feedback

    They used to have great Japanese denim, not sure what happened

  • Everlane makes high-quality products with reasonable prices. I love that the brand is transparent with materials and costs.

    Feedback

    Items can be out of stock for several months.