Cometeer Coffee

Cometeer Coffee

Cometeer Coffee reviews and discussion

4.3

85% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Consistently smooth, fresh flavor
  • Exceptionally convenient brewing method
  • Esteemed roaster partnerships lineup
  • Versatile hot-and-iced preparation
  • Bulky freezer storage requirement
  • Excessive, recyclable packaging waste
  • Limited box customization options
  • Occasional overly strong bitterness

Cometeer Coffee earns strong reviews for delivering cafe-level, smooth, fresh-tasting brews—especially iced—through flash‑frozen pods and partnerships with roasters like Counter Culture, Onyx, and George Howell, making high-quality coffee fast and foolproof. Reviews also flag real drawbacks: excess packaging and freezer bulk, limited customization, occasional bitter or too-strong cups, and a subscription model and operational missteps that frustrate some users.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

123 reviews and posts

  • Really cool concept! Great options from some of my favorite coffee shops, and the convenience is unmatched. Definitely a great pick if you have limited kitchen space. I learned about this brand when they did a demo in my office, and their team did a wonderful job explaining everything!

  • Really liked the coffee and so easy to use, but it seems like a lot of wasteful packaging and is a bit on the expensive side. If you want a quick option though it might be worth it.

  • Fair warning: I worked in the third-wave coffee industry and have invested heavily in our at-home coffee experience. I am always critical of "fast" coffee, but Cometeer has its place for the general coffee hobbyist or the higher-end aficionado. While they can take up some precious freezer space, the truth is that these pods are 10x the taste and quality of any other instant coffee that I've had so far. I personally love the light and bright options, which feature some of the top roasters in the country, like Onyx or Equator. Being able to try out different styles is a great option, and has led to me trying coffees from these roasters as a result. We try to always have a pack of these in the freezer for visitors or my parents, who don't feel confident grinding their own coffee and making an espresso or pourouver in the morning. Parents: If your time is limited and you only have 20-40 seconds to look away from your kiddo to make coffee, then this is the right fit! It was a god send in the first year of being a dad.

  • As someone frequently running between meetings while working from home, I'm usually keeping an eye out for anything that makes my mornings more efficient. Cometeer makes great coffee and is a big timesaver for people who don't have the time to grind and brew fresh cups in the morning. These capsules are just as easy to use for cold brew prep as they are for making drip coffee, though they definitely are on the expensive side.

  • I really enjoyed my cometeer coffee - I got the multipack with four different brands and loved them all. The option to get a mixed variety of roasts was appreciated and I could try several brands I haven't had before. It's also super convenient to use and I liked experimenting with making hot and cold coffees, putting the pod in my coffee machine, making lattes, etc. The only cons are it's a bit pricey and for me personally, it makes slightly less coffee than I'm used to having.

  • I was extremely impressed by the quality of each shot I tried. They were able to preserve the freshness and flavor of the espresso! And they were easy to thaw and accessible for my on-the-go days. Thinking more economically, the pods are technically cheaper per capsule than getting a double espresso shot at a coffee shop if you also factor in tips, alternative milks, etc. A big note to folks trying Comeeter: Please follow the storage instruction when your box arrives! Throw all the pods into your freezer STAT!

  • LOVE. Cometeer makes my mornings so much easier AND saves me money while tasting incredible.

  • I wanted to have a quick and easy coffee option in the mornings.

    Feedback

    The coffee is delicious and easy to make. Packaging is simple, clean and I love that it’s environmentally friendly!

  • I've subscribed Cometeer since trial. Good quality, can taste the flavor of power-over coffee. The only drawback, however, is it doesn't smell like coffee: concentration exile all scenes.

  • Skeptical at first, but honestly this product was such a surprise to me. Great for iced lattes and really helpful for days when I'm rushing out of the house.

  • i'd consider myself an intermediate coffee snob, and cometeer is actually super impressive in taste and very convenient!

  • I would love to give this company a higher rating, as the premise sounds incredible and the reviews even better for the flavor. However, the customer support from this company on the delivery of my product has been absolutely terrible. They say "oh the order was delayed" but they never told me of a delay until I had a chat with two people to find that out. "Oh we'll e-mail you with an update by tomorrow." Never happens. "We have no idea why it still says processing." Well can you ask someone? None of these things would be an issue if the company just e-mailed customers based off of updates as they come in, or at least stick to what they say they're going to do after speaking to a customer and giving them a specific timeline. I work in customer success, and this is basic etiquette in order to keep a job in this field. Its just frustrating, and I hope I can come back and change this review.

  • Had to throw out nearly 1/4 of the coffee I received due to a hole in the pods. Cometeer wouldn't replace the damaged items.

  • horrible business practice. I signed up for free trial and apparently there was a VERY fine print which meant I signed up for recurring shipments every month. They sent me a new shipment after the free trial and charged me $75. I called to explain that I didnt want that and didnt know I had inadvertently signed up for membership and I would be happy to return the coffee for refund. They refused to refund me and proceeded to charge me anyway. Buyer beware here! Really terrible customer service and sneaky business tactic.

  • 2 put of 4 of their flavors in my box were crap and when I reached out to them to improve the experience days before getting my second subscription order sent out they waited till last min to reply that they cant customize boxes and that I should opt for different box but when I asked for that option they dissmissed me and said that its too late to change my order. then i added a barista option to get a better variety brews that won’t just be thrown out and they lazily just added the same flavor as one of my others wtf? Terrible experience— in end paying $3+ per cup and feeling like an idiot — say they’re working on giving people option to customize but that won’t solve the dismissive customer service experience

    Former customer
  • I’ve been a subscriber for several years. BEST coffee on the planet, hands down! I look forward to rewarding myself every morning with a delicious cup of Cometeer. Delivery is efficient and flexible. Highest recommendation for this product.

  • I love this brand. My boyfriend loves cold brew and I like hot coffee, but in a small NYC apartment I do have room to do all the brewing things that coffee comes with. This makes it SIMPLE! My only caveat is that you have to run it under water for it to melt.