Boy Smells reviews and discussion

4.4

90% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Distinctive, complex fragrance profiles
  • Chic, giftable minimalist packaging
  • Impressive scent throw performance
  • Long, even candle burn duration
  • Inconsistent burn quality tunneling
  • Occasional sooty, smoky extinguish
  • Variable scent strength projection
  • Rare vessel and label defects

Boy Smells earns largely positive reviews for richly unique, room‑filling scents—standouts include Hinoki Fantôme, Cashmere Kush, Cowboy Kush, Cedar Stack, LES, and Slow Burn—and sleek, giftable packaging. Reviews also flag inconsistencies: tunneling and uneven burns, occasional weak throw or over‑potent scents depending on fragrance, sooting/smoky snuff‑outs, rare vessel defects, and mixed longevity in perfumes, making scent selection and burn care essential.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

729 reviews and posts

  • I own one of their candles and while none of the scents speak to me, they have a lot of longevity. I've had it for years and can still smell it when unlit.

    Feedback

    wider range of scents

  • I absolutely love these candles. They not only have a wide array of unisex smells, but the packaging is always top-notch. These candles are the absolute best present to give someone whether you get one larger size or the small teacup sets, everyone always adores them! I'm obsessed with both Cashmere Kush and Marble Fruit, will absolutely continue to repurchase!

  • The fragrances are nice/

    Feedback

    I have not had a great burning experience with these candles. They have not burned evenly which is frustrating and wasteful if not corrected with tinfoil.

  • I have two of their perfumes and have tried almost all of their candles. Their perfumes are unique and long lasting. Love that its unisex. Both my husband and I wear them. Violet Ends is my favorite with the floral and the smokiness. Candles: I haven't met one I didn't love. They all have great throw. Just make sure to trim your candle wicks.

  • These candles have such a unique, delicious smell. My absolute favorite is Hinoki Fantome. I also love Cashmere Kush. They are super potent and last a long time. Super expensive, but I bought a set of three during a black friday sale (in 2021) and I still have 1 whole more candle to finish.

  • Long burning candles that smell incredible and can mask any other scent.

  • Fantastic scents and good quality. Obsessed with “Park Life”

  • I LOVE Boy Smells candles. One of the few "status candles" that feels like a still relatively attainable price point, and think the scents / branding is a bit less stuffy compared to others. My favorite scents are Cowboy Kush and Hinoki Fantome, but I honestly haven't met a scent I didn't like.

  • this brand is a scent-lover’s dream! the scents are so unique and really add life to any room - whether or not you burn the candle! burn time is pretty average, packaging is sleek and simple, and the scent payoff is great! these make amazing gifts!

  • these candles smell great (subtle; not too fragrant) + last awhile! I have 3 different ones right now + will definitely be purchasing more in the future.

    Feedback

    n/a

  • How many candles have I bought from Boy Smells? I always have one on my desk, and I light it when I'm starting to feel an afternoon work slump. It started with a gift from a friend, and then I just started buying them myself. We gave one to my brother's girlfriend for Christmas and now SHE's buying them for herself too! Contagious and addictive.

  • Shipping was very fast, and everything was packaged carefully so that nothing would break.

    Feedback

    The smells here are very unique, and it looks so good in any room. I just wish the scent was just a bit stronger. I can definitely smell it when it's not lit, but when I do light it, there are times I can barely smell it at all.

  • I really love this brand's scents and their overall message. Their St. Al candle is one of my all time favorites, however they discontinued it which is a bummer. I will say I've always experienced tunneling no matter what candle I've had of theirs, but to be fair I haven't purchased a candle since they rebranded and changed their packaging, so hopefully they fixed that.

  • The name cracked me up. I saw a bunch of these on a table with other gifts (and one lit) inside of a vintage store in Piedmont, CA. It smelled good, but of all the candle choices available, I wouldn't purchase this one.

  • The cutest candles - I think these make such a great gift for a friend or family member.

  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Boy Smells candles offer an array of captivating scents that add a delightful ambiance to any space. Their sleek design and high-quality wax ensure a clean and long-lasting burn, making them a reliable choice for enhancing relaxation or setting the mood. While some scents may be more subtle than others, the overall experience is still enjoyable. I appreciate the brand's commitment to inclusivity and modern aesthetics, which adds to their charm. With a diverse range of fragrances to choose from, Boy Smells candles are a stylish addition to any home or gift idea for loved ones.