Unreal Snacks reviews and discussion

4.4

89% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Cleaner-label ingredient list
  • Satisfying dark chocolate flavor
  • Lower-sugar sweet treat
  • Vegan-friendly product options
  • Occasionally dry peanut butter filling
  • Chalky, dusty peanut texture
  • Bitterness for sweeter palates
  • Palm oil ingredient concern

Unreal Snacks wins praise in reviews for tasting like upgraded versions of Reese’s, M&M’s, and Mounds—especially the dark chocolate peanut butter cups, coconut bars, and crispy quinoa gems—while using cleaner ingredients and less sugar. However, critiques surface around dryness in some nut-butter cups, occasional chalky or dusty textures, strong dark-chocolate bitterness for sweet-tooth palates, use of palm oil, and inconsistent flavor in gems; several reviewers also note that it doesn’t always replicate classic candies and can disappoint those expecting exact dupes.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

180 reviews and posts

  • Great alternative to traditional candy that doesn't compromise on taste at all! They have single serving pouches and larger bags too, my fav is the dark chocolate crispy quinoa gems

  • I love these products. They are all so delicious!

    Feedback

    Never been disappointed and I think I’ve tried everything they make. The almond butter cups are amazing and I’m not even an almond butter person. Probably my favorite treat!

  • If you haven't tried the Unreal brand of peanut butter cups, you don't know what you're missing!! They are absolutely delicious. If you've ever made homemade peanut butter cups before, the flavor is reminiscent of that. It has less sugar than traditional Reese's peanut butter cups but certainly does not lack flavor!

  • Get these candies! I am always looking for "healthier" ways to satisfy my sweet tooth. My favorite candy is almond Joy so finding that they had a chocolate coconut bar was amazing!!!

  • I LOVED the unreal dark chocolate coconut bars! The macros on them were amazing and I would 10/10 recommend!

    None
  • My family loves unreal chocolate. The dairy free options are on point and taste better than their dairy competitors. We love the dark chocolate peanut butter cups, dark chocolate coconut bars,dark chocolate peanut gems and dark chocolate quinoa gems.

  • Love the little chocolate gems but the peanut butter cups weren't my favorite.

  • I tried the coconut candy one and it is delicious

  • the dark chocolate peanut butter cups are divine and hit different on halloween after a bit of punch

  • This is one of the brands that I give preference now. Is healthier and the taste is amazing. Higher quality and it has a good relation between cost and benefits.

  • Tastes just like Reece's, but not as sweet which is what I like about them. Enjoy guilt free.

  • As someone who is dairy-free, finding a "Reese's" that I am able to eat is GAME CHANGING! I am obsessed with UNREAL Peanut butter cups to the point that people know if they see them while are shopping to buy them for me. In my opinion, these peanut butter cups actually taste way better than Reese's and other competing brands. The dark chocolate is rich and super tasty and the peanut butter is sweet but perfectly balanced. I am a little upset however that some of their other products have "milk" as a ingredient. As someone who loves their peanut butter cups, I cant count how many times I've bought and come home with their milk chocolate gems by accident. I know they have the quinoa dark chocolate gems, but I wish they had plain chocolate "non-dairy" gems.

  • Yummy! Rare to find a healthy-er alternative that is actually maybe even better tasting than the real thing. Curbs candy cravings without leaving you feeling sickly sweet or having a strange health food after taste. Like others have said, a bit on the pricier side but you can pick up a bulk bag of the coconut bars at Costco and it gives you a better bang for your buck.

  • Unreal Dark Chocolate Coconut Bars are packed with coconut flavor without being overly sweet. The chocolate is high quality with just the right amount of sweetness that you look forward to each little treat.

  • Great lower sugar treats. Keep the dark chocolate peanut butter and coconut bars in the cupboard. The single serving packaging makes them perfect for lunch tuck ins (tho not especially friendly for the environment). If I were to change one thing it would be packaging them in a sustainable and compostable wrapper instead of the plastic foil.

  • Obsessed with the quinoa gems. They’re crunchy and chocolatey without a total sweetness overload. They’re awesome to snack on and make great ice cream toppings too. Their dark chocolate peanut butter cups are one of my faves too. Love the company’s mission and clean, fair trade ingredients.

    Feedback

    If there was any way to make the peanut butter cups a softer chocolate, I would be in heaven!

  • Love the peanut butter cups, an incredible alternative if you're looking for something with less sugar!

  • If I could give these 1000/10, I would. They taste incredible and help keep my blood sugar in normal range. Satisfies my sweet tooth too :)

    Customer
  • I like them simply because I feel our foods should have less sugar and flavor is not compromised