3.9
72% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
SmartSweets
3.9 • 1,536 Reviews
•
SmartSweets reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Vivid, nostalgic flavors
- Lower‑sugar candy formulas
- Convenient portion packs
- Vegan, plant‑based options
- Extremely sticky texture
- Inconsistent chew quality
- Notable sweetener aftertaste
- Potential gi discomfort
SmartSweets earns largely positive reviews as a lower‑sugar candy that satisfies cravings—standouts include Sweet Fish, Peach Rings, Sourmelon Bites, red twists, and gummy worms—while recurring complaints in reviews cite an extremely sticky, tooth‑clinging texture and occasional odd or stevia‑like aftertaste. Reviews also note inconsistent chew across flavors and batches, plus some GI sensitivity for a few users; if you want a healthier candy fix and can accept a different chew, SmartSweets is a compelling swap, but purists may prefer the originals.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
1,536 reviews and posts
4y ago
I love these! The Swedish fish were a little wet if that makes sense but all the other flavors I’ve loved.
4y ago
Great alternative to a high sugary treat.
Feedback
Not too in love with the flavors.
4y ago
The packaging is cute and has attractive writing. The best part I love about the SmartSweets is the low sugar content, 4 grams, and without compromising the taste! They are vegan friendly too, which is important for some.
Feedback
I don’t think there’s anything that could be better, the candy is good and the packaging is straightforward in what the ingredients are!
4y ago
I tried the peach rings and was quite dissatisfied by the texture of the candy itself. The taste itself is alright, but the texture was too gummy almost like taffy. At least they’re sugar free as a benefit, but I wouldn’t buy them again.
Feedback
I wish they were a bit more peach forward, and if there is some way to change the texture to be a bit more firm.
4y ago
I really enjoy all SmartSweets products! They taste very similar to the higher sugar products and have a great texture.
Feedback
I wish there was more product in the bags and the price is a little steep.
4y ago
Satisfies a sweet craving. Some flavors are better than others. Swedish fish flavor is best. Very chewy and get stuck on teeth.
4y ago
Tastes pretty chemically, but I guess all dummies are kinda like that. Healthy version of gummy bears for sure. would recommend.
Feedback
Solid experience.
4y ago
Feedback
I loved some of there products! It tasted amazing and nice for people with illnesses trying to balance blood sugar, the Swedish fish gummies are my favourite
4y ago
Overall, the product is good to kick the sweet craving, but it doesn't quite hit the same. The texture of the gummies is very different than you'd expect. Majority of the flavors are good, but at some point you can really taste the artificial-ness.
Feedback
I think changing the texture of gummies would be a huge game-changer. If you're looking for a sweet, low calorie snack, these are great. But for an alternative to your favorite gummy, I'm not sure it'll be what you're looking for.
4y ago
A good alternative for sweets when you don’t want all of the usual sugar. Fun variety and overall great taste.
Feedback
Overall pretty great, the red fish however are a bit slimy inside the bag.
4y ago
Feedback
Super tasty treats!! But not sure if the pricing is valuable enough for me to purchase again.
4y ago
I really wanted to enjoy SmartSweets! I tried the gummies in Sweet Fish, Peach RIngs, Sourmelon Bites and Sour Blast Buddies. Unfortunately, they tasted artificial so I won't be purchasing them again.
4y ago
These sweets definitely taste and feel different from the regular gummy. Some flavours are sticky and gooey and have a weird consistency (ie. sour patch kids). The Swedish fish are slightly more like a normal ju-jube texture and because of its familiarity, I was a bigger fan of those. Despite its claim of having less than X amount of sugar, the gummies still made my teeth feel coated with sugar afterwards so they didn’t feel much healthier.
Feedback
Not the best gummies and too pricey for the amount you get per package. They’re candies that cater to the millennial who is willing to pay a premium for good marketing.
4y ago
I loved every candy they made but their cola candy, chefs kiss!! Love that they’re giving us healthier but still tasty candy options.
4y ago
These are delicious! I love the Peach Rings flavor almost better than OG peach rings – they’re chewy and have just the right amount of tartness and sweetness. They curb my cravings for sweets and don’t make me feel gross after.
4y ago
I had the peach rings and fishies. They definitely satisfied my sweet cravings without all the sugar in regular sweets. Does it taste like regular candy? No, but prob the best alternative there is.
Feedback
Love the packaging and the use of actual pictures of the candy on the packaging. I get this sense of reassurance knowing exactly what's inside the package before I even open it.
4y ago
Love the fish the most! Tastes very similar but way more healthy
4y ago
I used to absolutely adore these candies, but recently found the formula must have changed because they get stuck in my teeth terribly now!
Feedback
Go back to the old formula!
4y ago
Certain kinds are good but not all. Texture varies from the type of sweets you get. Peach rings are good but I would avoid the cola and sour blast buddies.
Feedback
Taste and texture can improve
4y ago
I’ve only tried a few of the sweets out but my favorite has to be the peach rings. Though I think they definitely could have more flavor, they make small add ons to gifts!