4.1
77% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Rothy's
4.1 • 112 Reviews
•
Rothy's reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Washable, durable construction
- Sustainable, recycled materials ethos
- Polished, versatile silhouettes
- Comfortable, no break‑in knit
- Inconsistent, confusing sizing
- Narrow, uncomfortable toe boxes
- Thin, unsupportive insoles
- Occasional odor retention
Rothy’s earns largely positive reviews for comfortable, machine‑washable shoes that look polished, hold up for years, and showcase sustainable materials, while feedback flags inconsistent sizing, narrow toe boxes, thin soles, and minimal arch support. Reviews of Rothy’s highlight standout styles like The Point, ballet flats, loafers, drivers, slip‑on and lace‑up sneakers, and clogs; buyers praise durability and versatility but caution about odor retention, fit variability, and limited options for wide feet.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
113 reviews and posts
My favorite and most used pair of "the sneaker" shoes are my Rothy shoes! I love them- they're so comfortable and I feel like a modern, trendy woman wearing them. I also have another pair of the Mary Janes that are very cute.
Feedback
I'd love to see a little more colors- I love wearing pink so I am always watching for new releases or sites like Depop for pink Rothy shoes.
5y ago
I love the concept of these flats & the sustainability story behind them. The colorways were limited when I first tried this product but have expanded nicely over time with a good selection of solid colors. They are genuinely comfortable and structured enough such that it doesn't look or feel like you are wearing knit slippers. I originally bought two pairs, hoping they would make the perfect "polished" travel shoe for business trips.
Feedback
Unfortunately, the washability value prop is questionable. I've tried washing them by hand as well as in the washing machine and unfortunately, the poly is quite good at trapping odor so they start to feel gross, like your standard leather flats, over time. I put one pair through the dry cycle just to see if it would make a difference and they shrank about half a size (to Rothy's credit, I don't think this is recommended care). I understand that they now sell replacement insoles to extend the longevity but I bought these in hopes of consuming less so this defeats the purpose.
I love my Rothys. I have two pairs of the pointe Shoes. I purchased them back before 2019 and they are still doing well. I like that they can be washed. You definitely need to otherwise they can smell.
Feedback
I have a stain on my red pair that I cannot seem to get out entirely. It’s not as obvious now but I can see it. I still love the shoes though.
I've had my Rothy's since 2016 and they're still holding up perfectly. The sole hasn't worn out and they've withstood thunderstorms, tons of walking, and numerous trips through the washing machine. I love that I don't have to worry whether my shoes will get destroyed by the weather. Goes with almost everything.
Feedback
Only one style seems to work with my foot shape and I feel like the same is true for others I know. It seems like everyone has one style that works for them, but the other styles pinch or gives blisters or something. I know people who wear the loafer, the round toe flat, and I wear the point toe flat.
1y ago
love my rothys!! i have a pair of flats as well as "the casual crossbody" and love them both :) i use the purse practically everyday and found it very easy to clean. definitely more on the pricey side - i do really like how their products are made from recycled materials though
3y ago
Super comfy for all day wear. Kinda pricey though.
3y ago
I had these shoes as a present from this brand and so far I'm liking them, although they are not a perfect fit for me although they double checked it was my size. They are not bad compared to other alternatives but not best either. Overall they are pretty nice and comfortable
3y ago
I ordered the "Lace Up Sneakers" in white since I was looking for a casual but still stylish everyday sneaker. They are incredibly comfortable and can easily spend a whole day walking around the city. Would recommend.
Feedback
They are machine washable - however, as with most white sneakers, they still aren't fully white after a wash!
Sale or special offer3y ago
Customer Service is Terrible I just ordered 4 pairs of flats. (2 of the same style in different sizes so I could see which size fit better). I did this b/c the website says to size up so, not ever purchasing Rothy's before, I was unsure of my exact size. When I received the shoes I see that they are part of a final sale. I contact Rothy's and they will not offer me any solution to the problem. No credit, no exchange and no return. Yes, I should've paid more attention when purchasing, but I find it to be incredibly poor customer service for a company that charges so much for a pair of flats. It will take me a great deal of time and effort to find someone to buy the shoes from me and likely I will just have to give them away so I'm out $160. I will never buy Rothy's again.
Feedback
Buy 1/2 size up.
4y ago
Shoes are heavy and high quality. Went up a size due to their recommendation (wide feet) but the toe box still wasn’t quite right. Love the color and that the shoes are washable and comfy.
Feedback
Would love wide widths.
4y ago
I’ve had my slip ons for over a year and they’re almost good as new even though I wear them daily! Which means they are comfortable and work with most of my outfits.
Feedback
I feel like they run a little small.
4y ago
Genuinely LOVE these shoes. I wear them to work daily so the washable function is my best friend for smelly feet. I could walk for decades in these!