Oatly reviews and discussion

4.3

85% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Creamy, milklike mouthfeel
  • Exceptional frothing performance
  • Versatile, coffee-enhancing flavor
  • Consistent, barista-grade texture
  • Additive-heavy ingredient list
  • Occasionally too sweet taste
  • Watery low‑fat variant texture
  • Potential gut sensitivity reports

Oatly impresses in reviews for creamy, café-worthy performance—especially Barista Edition, which froths reliably and elevates lattes, matcha, and espresso—while its distinct oat flavor works across coffee, cereal, baking, and smoothies. Reviews also flag meaningful drawbacks: frequent concerns about additives/oils, sweetness and blood-sugar impact, occasional separation or watery low‑fat variants, and mixed reactions to texture; fans call it the best-tasting oat milk, but ingredient purists and some sensitive stomachs report issues.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

2,462 reviews and posts

  • Oatly Barista Edition oat milk is has a very creamy texture and ability to froth well, it is the best choice for coffee and other beverages like tea for me works very well well in the morning. Makes my coffee the best!!

  • I like to switch up my milks but I’ve been a repeat offender of Oatly. I like that it has a neutral yet rich flavor, and it is quite versatile in coffee or in cooking. I threw a splash in a batch of meatballs and they were delicious.

  • I absolutely love Oatly's oat milk products! I liked that they offer different refrigerated and shelf-stable options to suit different needs; I also liked how great their milk's taste and texture are - so rich and smooth, they are literally making regular coffee tastes better.

  • Oatly is my favorite oat milk, it's super creamy, slightly sweet, and perfect in coffee. The Barista Edition froths really well and tastes amazing in lattes. It’s also great in cereal or smoothies. A little pricier than some, but totally worth it for the taste and quality.

  • I always like having some shelf stable milk on hand. It’s very convenient and you never know when you might need it. The flavor of this oat milk is very good and the ingredients are pretty clean. I would buy it again.

  • This is our favorite milk. Love using it in cereal as well as in smoothies. It is full of so much flavor and is thick! I love that it has good ingredients as well. Costs the same as several others as well

  • The Barista Oat Milk is a really great option for making matcha lattes at home. It helps elevate that to a cafe quality! The texture is smooth, rich, and creamy, and the taste is fantastic. Fun packaging design as well.

  • I love Oatly! Of all the oat milk brands out there, it’s my favorite across taste and texture. My matcha latte routine is incomplete without the barista edition in particular — it’s so frothy and creamy and the nuttiness balances the matcha so well. My one feedback would be an ask for cleaner ingredients/less stabilizers in their barista recipe! I’m giving them 4 stars because of this. Long term I may opt to make oat milk myself in search of a diet with less processed foods, but it does the trick for now!

  • Oatly Barista is not just your average dairy alternative – it's a creamy, sustainable, and downright delicious addition to your morning routine. As a devoted coffee enthusiast, I've explored various milk alternatives, but Oatly Barista stands out for its exceptional taste and performance.

    Friends with Oatly
  • This is the only oatmilk I buy. No store brands or other brands come close to matching the texture, creaminess, and flavor. Another highlight is its versatility. Other oatmilks are only good in cereal (in my opinion), but Oatly works great in cereal and smoothies and coffee too. The only thing I would improve is the cost. It’s often a dollar or two more expensive in stores than other brands, however it’s still worth it to me.

  • Oatly is my favorite non dairy milk brand and I love the ice cream. It might not be the cleanest option, but it definitely tastes the best. I also like the simple version for no added ingredients. Will keep purchasing.

  • Taste & texture are the best of all oat milks out there. Their brand is light hearted and the carton is fun to read. The barista edition is easy to grip and pour from for my daily morning coffee station.

    Feedback

    Usually pretty expensive even on sale

  • Oatly is my Favorite for everything! New addiction is Oatly with tea omGGGG game changer ;) I love it so much I have it in a small & large :p

  • I've never tasted any milk or milk alternative better than Oatley. I love making my morning latte with the Barista edition or full fat edition every morning and their branding is tops!

    Feedback

    Produce more, it's always sold out and so hard to find in Copenhagen!

  • It's the best compared to others in the supermarket, quite rich in flavor, and has a slight thickness, without tasting like dirty water. I often get the regular one although the barista version is definitely a must. The first time I bought it, it was because the packaging was quite creative and 'speaking' to me, just as every step in the customer experience makes it easier to understand while reading. It's out of the box, innovative and I connected with it, besides being tasty and my favorite for coffee made at home. I'm also UGC creator and if you would like a visual review, that cou

  • I'm absolutely in love with Oatly Barista! Its creamy texture is a dream, especially when mixed with my matcha and hot chocolate - it creates the perfect blend. As someone who isn't a fan of cow's milk, this has been a fantastic alternative. It froths up beautifully, adding a smooth, rich dimension to my beverages.

    None
  • One of the standout features of Oatly is its texture. It is thick and creamy, with a consistency that is similar to whole milk. It's also very versatile and can be used in a variety of ways, from adding to coffee and tea to using in recipes that call for dairy milk.

    Feedback

    Another great thing about Oatly is that it is made from sustainable ingredients. Oats are a more environmentally friendly crop than dairy, so by choosing Oatly, you are making a more sustainable choice.

    Influencer for Oatly
  • By far the best oat milk out there - dare I say the best non-dairy milk out there. I've never been disappointed with Oatly. I know it's mostly branded as the barista's choice, but I love using it for my cereal as well. Those who like a little more of an oat-y flavor will definitely be able to get behind this one as well. Great flavor, great consistency, and great branding. Each carton comes with different packaging and they're all honestly so entertaining to read. So, in addition to a great product, I also have to give it to them for stellar branding!

  • This dairy alternative foams exceptionally well compared to all of the other oat drinks that I've tried! It also makes an ultra creamy mocha.

    Feedback

    I'd love to see this product available in more grocery stores. To date, I've only found it through a specialty coffee store online.

  • I've tried Chobani, Planet Earth, Califia Farms, Trader Joe's house brand, and a few other oat milk brands and can confidently say that Oatly (Regular, Full Fat, and Barista Edition) is by far the best. - High quality and doesn't separate in coffee, which is critical - Tastes great; doesn't overly taste like oat - Smooth consistency - Versatile. It's great with coffee, chai, or as a milk substitute with granola/cereal - Froths well

    Feedback

    - Oatly still doesn't have a strong distribution network where I live; hard to find sometimes so have to settle for other brands - It has a high sugar content–14% so don't always feel great about drinking it