3.5
58% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Magic Spoon
3.5 • 1,202 Reviews
•

3.5
58% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Magic Spoon largely satisfies those seeking a healthier, high‑protein, low‑sugar riff on nostalgic cereals, according to reviews, but it is not universally loved. Reviewers praise its 13g protein per serving, gluten‑free/grain‑free formulas, fun flavors like Fruity, Cocoa, Cinnamon Roll, and Maple Waffle, and cheerful packaging; common complaints cite an artificial or stevia/monk‑fruit aftertaste, gummy texture that sticks to teeth, flavor inconsistency (especially some chocolate/peanut butter variants), limited satiety for some, and very small, pricey boxes.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
The most delicious cereal! If you’re on keto, this will save you! Go buy it!
This is the best cereal on the market! So tasty, great nutrition, and good price point!
I tried the peanut butter flavor because I was told it was the best one. I love cereal but I will never purchase this brand ever again. It tasted even more artificial to me than regular cereal, and I ended up throwing away half of the box when we always try to finish and not waste food. Gave 2 stars for the attempt at a “healthy” cereal.
Didn't feel it was worth the hype... there are better ways to support a keto diet.
3y ago
Rather eat sugary cereal. Tastes are all off and very cardboard like texture
Didn’t love the taste nor the price. It wasn’t very filling.
I feel like influencers are paid way too much because this does not taste like the other store brands. I can eat it but my toddler won’t even eat it
Overall, it is a very tasty and crunchy cereal. I’ve tried the cinnamon circles variety. I am very sensitive to the taste of artificial sweeteners, and the taste is there but the cinnamon helps mask it quite a lot! Excited to try a fruity cereal next!
3y ago
Such a fun brand. These are delicious and nostalgic.
Not my favorite. The flavors I’ve tried have all been kind of like munching on packing peanuts. I’ve really tried to like them, but they keep letting me down.
So so good, definitely worth the hype! I tried the fruity flavor and it was unreal! Very good, and worth the hype!
I was a huge cereal person as a kid but as an adult cut down on sugars. I received this as a gift but GOODNESS I am soooo glad I did. This product brings me back to my childhood but also fills me up and doesn't give me the sugar jitters. I love the cocoa one with oat milk the best :)
I enjoyed these cereals as a snack, but I cannot say my toddler enjoyed them.
I haven’t eaten traditional cereal in a while so I decided to give a these a chance and surprisingly thought they were very good. When you realize it’s “healthier” cereal I think it’s definitely something I would eat again.
Feedback
Just a cosmetic critique but I don’t love the box lol. Traditional cereal boxes have a lot going on and I just felt these were a little plain.
LOVEEEE Magic Spoon cereals! The taste is absolutely amazing. I love that they are so high in protein, yet lower in carbs than traditional cereal. My favorite is the fruity flavor! :)
The flavors are good and it has a nice crunch. However, it is made with whey protein and so it hurts my stomach.
I was looking for a good low carb cereal and tried this brand. I ordered all the flavors to try. The only one I really liked was the fruity one and it was so good! The other two flavors had this weird after taste. I would continue to buy if it wasn’t so pricey
As someone who can only eat gluten free, this cereal is hands down the best cereal I have ever had. Such unique and fun flavours! Absolutely recommend!
I'm loving this brand. They've taken something as nostalgic as cereal and made it healthy without sacrificing taste. I've been enjoying their cereals for a while now, and I'm seriously impressed. The flavors available are quite diverse, catering to different taste buds. From fruity to chocolaty, there's something for everyone. The texture is also enjoyable, with a nice crunch that reminds one of classic cereals.
Great tasting cereal without all the added stuff. I didn't believe it was possible. My only challenge is its hard not to finish a box in 1-2 days, with a pricepoint that is hard to consume regularly. There is not a better cereal option out there; the peanut butter flavor was my personal favorite. The critiques about how it can make your mouth feel kind of weird are true, but it is not weird enough to keep me from more magic spoons in and around my mouth.