Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

4.7

95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Velvety, creamy texture
  • Inventive, distinctive flavors
  • High-quality, clean ingredients
  • Strong dairy-free options
  • Overly sweet for some palates
  • Inconsistent flavor intensity
  • Icy texture after refreezing
  • Rich, heavy mouthfeel

Jeni's Ice Creams wins praise in reviews for its ultra-creamy texture, inventive flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, and strong dairy-free/gluten-free options—so yes, the brand is good. Reviews also flag drawbacks: many find it very sweet and rich, inconsistently punchy by flavor, prone to freezer burn or iciness in pints, and expensive compared to alternatives.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,841 reviews and posts

  • Brambleberry Crisp changed my world. I love the brick and mortar stores, as well as shipping options. It’s also great that I can find in my local grocery stores.

  • There's a Jeni's close to Charlotte, NC. I tried the blackberry flavor and it was to die for!!! Plus, you get a free cup or cone on your birthday :) Creamy, tasty, delicious!!

  • Jeni’s will always be my favorite. So many interesting and unique flavors, perfect texture, and love that they are always rolling out new flavors.

    Feedback

    Keep up the great work!

  • This is the best ice cream EVER. The Sweet Cream Biscuits and Peach Jam? Each spoonful is like a little bite of heaven. Don't even get me started on the Darkest Chocolate or the Boston Cream Pie. Jeni's is opening a new location in Winter Park, FL and you best believe I'll be there at least once a week. Until then, I'll keep grabbing pints at Publix.

  • Jeni's was the dessert at my wedding. The crowd went wild for the mini Jeni's ice creams during a heat wave in Nashville. Not only are the single servings the perfect size, but the flavors are also delicious and guests really enjoyed the experience.

    Feedback

    Couldn't have better things to say about Jeni's. Your Nashville staff at the East Nashville location was extremely wonderful to work with and went above and beyond to help me keep my wedding ice creams cold on a heat wave day last June.

  • We've been obsessed with Jeni's since the early days of the Short North Columbus, Ohio scoop shop. The quality, the tasting profiles, and the overall experience make it my favorite ice cream on this planet (And boy have I tried a few). Not only do you get quality ingredients and a beautiful brand experience, but you get to know and love that its coming from passionate people who want to create the best of the best.

  • The ice cream is delicious, and the flavors are super unique! A bit on the pricier side for a pint of ice cream but I think they're a non-profit, so it makes me want to support them more!

  • Best ice cream in the world! The innovative flavors paired with the creamy texture makes every tasting a treat. I love that there are so many dairy free options that still have incredible flavor - great to make ice cream delicious without the tummyache.

    Feedback

    I wish there were more scoop shops that were accessible in NYC to try products on a more frequent basis!

  • We simply can't pass the ice cream cooler without picking up a Jeni's- especially if there's a new flavor we haven't tried. So far they are all my favorite, except for the bagel & cream cheese flavor, that one was just a little TOO on point. Currently we're trying Wedding Cake and it's delicious! I love the cake bits. The Watermelon Taffy flavor tastes EXACTLY like watermelon laffy taffy, in the best way possible

  • You just can't beat Jeni's. The flavors are so, so good and well worth the price.

  • If you have not tried this, then you are absolutely missing out!!! You NEED this asap. Best ice cream I have ever tried.

  • Simply delicious! I. can't rave enough on how much I love the taste of this icecream! My go-to dessert after my dinner meal !

    Received a free product from Jeni's Ice Creams
  • OMFG this is the best ice cream. Brambleberry crisp nearly brought me to tears. Boston cream pie? Legendary. Such a wonderful experience.

    Feedback

    The price point is pretty steep but the product is also super high quality so liiiiike fair.

  • Truly amazing ice cream and amazing flavors. I love that this is a small brand out of Atlanta. You can tell the products are made with good ingredients and care.