Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

4.7

95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Velvety, ultra-creamy texture
  • Inventive, distinctive flavors
  • Plentiful, well-distributed mix-ins
  • Impressive dairy-free options
  • Inconsistent flavor execution
  • Occasionally icy, grainy texture
  • Some flavors overly sweet
  • Variable creaminess across pints

Jeni's Ice Creams earns rapturous reviews for rich, ultra‑creamy texture and inventive, true‑to‑label flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, confirming the brand is excellent. Reviews also flag downsides: pints are expensive, quality varies by flavor, and some report iciness or overly sweet/salty notes and occasional freezer burn from stores.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,842 reviews and posts

  • OMFG this is the best ice cream. Brambleberry crisp nearly brought me to tears. Boston cream pie? Legendary. Such a wonderful experience.

    Feedback

    The price point is pretty steep but the product is also super high quality so liiiiike fair.

  • Truly amazing ice cream and amazing flavors. I love that this is a small brand out of Atlanta. You can tell the products are made with good ingredients and care.

  • Their goat cheese with red cherries is out of this world. I had it a few years ago and still think about it. One of the flavors that is truly unique. Have never ordered it so can't speak to the shipping, but the flavor is great.

  • Really good ice cream. I am lactose, and I love that they offer non-diary options that still feel rich in texture. The texas sheet flavor is my fave. I highly recommend.

    Feedback

    overall great experience

  • Delicious ice cream and the flavors are so much fun. Really love their limited edition partnerships. Plus the packaging is vibrant and eye catching.

  • They have amazing flavors and some great dairy-free options! Plus their packaging is always cute : - )

  • We are lucky enough to have a Jeni's down the street from us. Their ice cream is top level, from the flavors, to the textures, to the customer care in-store. I've also ordered online as gifts and the e-commerce experience was perfection. They make great gifts; they ship on a scheduled date and arrive in good condition.

    Feedback

    Delicious! Thanks!

  • Jenis ice cream is really good. I saw it on Doordash and had to order it , especially because of the bright packaging. Flavor is great, its really sweet but hey its ice cream!

  • If ice cream could be luxurious then Jeni’s would own the title! The flavors are such unique combos that mend together so well.

    Feedback

    I alway wish that I purchased more than 1 pint at a time as it is so good that you always want seconds!

  • Flavor is okay but definitely not a replacement to real ice cream. I’m a bit of a purist here, so this may not be the case for everyone.

  • Jenni why are you so expensive!! The flavors are really good but they’re not $5 better than Ben & Jerry’s. Definitely will only be buying this for special occasions or if I’m really dying to try a flavor.

    Feedback

    Price is so much more expensive than other ice cream brands

  • Absolutely obsessed with jennies ice cream. There is no ice cream better than gooey butter cake.

  • Jennis is so good all the time. My favorite flavor is the butter cake but all the seasonal flavors keep me coming back.

  • Jeni's is the best! The Branbleberry crisp is simply perfect and they have so many other unique flavors so that anyone can find what they like and are looking for. I love the fun packaging and how creamy the ice cream is.

  • Every. Single. Flavor. Is. Amazing.

    Feedback

    Even if it *sounds* like a flavor you’re unsure of, try it! Because it’s probably the best thing you’ve ever tasted.

  • The first time I tried Jeni's ice cream, I stood in line at the ice cream shop for about 35 minutes before I ordered a waffle cone filled with two scoops of the seasonal orange blossom flavor, and I would do it again and again. What's even more impressive, is that the pints found in grocery stores taste just as good as it would if you stood in line for 35 minutes, too.

    Feedback

    Almost every flavor that Jeni's offers is perfect, but I wish that flavors like orange blossom or sunshine were more accessible; or really any citrusy flavors- even if it were seasonally.