I tried it once because the glass bottle always caught my attention, but I didn't think it would be that great because milk is milk. BUT, it literally changed my mind because this milk was so creamy, thick, and the taste was just different from other milk brands. I rarely drink whole milk though so it was like a treat, almost like ice cream. I also really like the bottle itself and have reused it.
Thingtesting is an unbiased place to research and review internet-born brands — because honest reviews help us all shop better. Learn more.
Hartzler Dairy Reviews
Very creamy flavorful whole milk. Love the glass bottle!
Maybe offer non dairy alternatives
We tried Hartzler milk on a whim as we saw they were sourced locally and were committed to offering a healthy product. Since trying it we are hooked! It is now the only milk we buy. They have skim, 2% and whole milk options in addition, they offer a full sized chocolate milk (which is heavenly) and a eggnog version during the holidays. Even cooler - they offer mini milks in fun flavors (orange, berry, strawberry, vanilla, chocolate) which are all delicious! My personal favorite is the vanilla version as it is wonderful in coffee, or added to hot chocolate. I highly recommend!
I would love to see the strawberry and vanilla version in full size. The vanilla is perfect for cofffee as a coffee creamer alternative. I think some additional seasonal flavors would be fun too - ex: pumpkin spice.
The old-school glass packaging, branding, the high quality product and the wide range of products makes this company worth watching and following. Their chocolate milk has the best flavor as well as texture. It almost makes you forgive yourself for indulging in it