Lidstar Glistening Eye Glow

4.5 • 2 Reviews

I've been shopping with Glossier since the early days and have seen it go from being the "it girl" brand of the 2010s to something much less distinctive in the market. However, the products I've called out here have stood the test of time for me as the absolute easiest options to get ready with that I know I can trust. The Gen G lipstick in Fuzz is always in my bag because it goes with everything, and the Lidstar in Cub is what I use on 70% of the days I wear makeup. They're fantastic for a sheer wash of color that (at least on my skin) lasts most of the day and can basically be applied without looking in the mirror. Similarly, after trying every option under the sun, I always return to Balm Dotcom and Boy Brow because they are just foolproof. They may not be the only cool option anymore, but the products hold up and I'll continue buying them. PS - the solid perfume is overlooked as an amazing gift. The packaging is luxurious metal/magnetic and I love carrying it with me in my bag.

I bought Slip after reading the description and studying the photos, hoping for a soft wash of golden shimmer that would last all day without creasing. On me, the reality was different. The shade reads very sheer and leans silvery rather than golden, which made it look ashy against my skin tone. Even with careful application and three layers, the payoff stayed faint and a little uneven. It also creased within a few hours and settled into fine lines, which took away from the polished effect I was going for. After some wear time it started to feel a bit dry on my lids. There are positives. The formula feels lightweight at first and blends quickly, so it is easy to apply if you like minimal makeup. The shimmer itself is pretty under lights and gives a quiet twinkle that some people will love. If you want a very subtle hint of sparkle that is almost undetectable at first glance, Slip can deliver that kind of look. Since I bought this online, I recognize that expectations can miss the mark. To help shoppers like me, I think it would be useful if the brand stated whether other products were used in the model photos and if a primer was involved. More swatches on a wider range of skin tones and a clear one-swipe versus three-layer comparison would also set expectations. I included two wrist swatches in my review, one swipe on the left and three layers on the right. For my needs, Slip did not match the description and was not flattering. For someone who wants barely-there shimmer and does not mind reapplying, it could still be a fit.