Fishwife reviews and discussion

4.5

89% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Vibrant, giftable packaging design
  • Consistently flavorful, high-quality fish
  • Ethical, sustainability-forward sourcing
  • Versatile, recipe-friendly selections
  • Small portions per tin
  • Occasionally dry cod texture
  • Overly smoky flavor variants
  • Inconsistent flavor intensity

Fishwife earns strong reviews for genuinely tasty, high-quality tinned seafood—standouts include Smoked Rainbow Trout, Smoked Albacore Tuna, and Fly By Jing Smoked Salmon—paired with striking, giftable packaging and an ethics-forward sourcing ethos. Reviews also flag meaningful drawbacks: small portions, frequent dryness or intense smokiness in certain SKUs (notably Campfire Cod), inconsistent flavor intensity, and a price that many consider steep for everyday use.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

219 reviews and posts

  • I must say I am disappointed. I expected this fish to be beyond good. It is a bit dry and too salty. These little tins cost $10 to $13 dollars EACH. Ridiculous. I am so tired of companies claiming to be all ethical and great only to deliver a mediocre product. ALSO, at this price, the fish should be wild-caught (which is what I expected). If it were wild-caught, it would say so. Only says "Atlantic Salmon" or Rainbow Trout" So you know damn well it is farmed. BOO to FishWife! I just wasted a lot of money. Save your money, people, don´t be fooled.

  • I bought their smoked salmon with Sichuan chili crisp and it was so delicious! I loved the design of the package and I know I’ll be able to recognize it right away as Fishwife when I’m on the hunt for tin fish.

  • Found fishwife at am amazing, well curated provisional store by me and the bright colorful packaging jumped out at me. Because you can never have enough tin fish in your cabinet, grabbed some to include in my dinner that night and you can absolutely taste the freshness from each tin. Wasn't overloaded with oil either and the color of the fish was super rich. Amazing taste, can't wait to try the rest of the line

    Feedback

    I have to admit the packaging is what caught my eye on the shelves, but once I ate it and tasted the quality and freshness, I was hooked. Then I learned that it was woman owned and sustainably sourced in small batches which made me feel good about contributing and supporting. Can't wait to try other products in the line!

  • Loved the taste, packaging, and the really unique markets they sell at in LA. You could call me a sustainability omnivore. Meaning I'll eat meat if it meets a very high standard of sustainable farming (such as regenerative). There was basically no real info on where they source their fish so I wrote them to ask. I heard back within 48 hours with a full breakdown and I was really impressed. I just wish they showed this on their website or press material. It definitely deserves a 5 rating but I am aware that this isn't an accessible product from a cost perspective. I realize it's probably low margin due to the quality of the product but I hope there's a future where anyone can afford this.

    Feedback

    If you're on the fence because of the price but you're ok with a splurge, go for it. You won't be upset unless you're looking to feed a lot of people.

  • The smoked trout is delicious, the tuna has great flavor but can be a little dry.

  • Love the packaging so much that I had to buy, but then I tasted it and was just as impressed!!

    Feedback

    Love supporting local female run, independent businesses!

  • BEST EVER! I love the trout the best on good toast with kewpie and dijon. woot!

  • They charge nearly $10 for shipping, it’s been 4 days since I placed my order and they haven’t sent it out yet. It’s Saturday and I’m tired of waiting around so I’m canceling my order.

    Feedback

    Service

  • I am a true lover of tinned fish and I was SO excited to try Fishwife. I've had every single product and love them all! It's the best tinned fish around (also it's just so fun to look at, amazing branding). My favorite is the smoked tuna, I literally cannot eat another type of tuna because it simply doesn't compare. The Fly by Jing collaboration is also incredible, with the perfect amount of spice. Love that the website has a ton of recipes, too.

    Feedback

    No real feedback, just want more products :).

  • As a jew, i eat a ton of fish and more specifically tuna fish / tinned fish. I have tried several brands over the years but they were all more or less the same. Fishwife caught my eye with the really beautiful branding and i decided to give it a try. I ordered the smoked tuna to start and was blown away. Since then, I make sure to stay stocked on all the smokey trio and love love the Fly By Jing flavor.

    Invested in Fishwife
  • The canned fish community will never be the same now that these guys are in the mix. The salmon and tuna are top notch and the Fly by Jing collab was one of my favorites. Can't wait to continue adding this to my lunch/dinner rotation.

    Feedback

    Nothing! Love everything about this product.

  • it was love at first sight when i saw the package! and the rainbow trout was also the best fish in a can i have ever had. great for gifts! 10/10 would recommend

  • The packaging is so awesome, it makes something as gross as sardines totally giftable! :D As you can probably tell, I didn't buy this product for myself. My husband is a lover or sardines, anchovies, etc. and I thought this would be a nice surprise that we could both enjoy (me for the vibe, him for the product). He really liked the quality of the fish PLUS our 2 year old can't stop eating it...which is shocking but also says something about how good this stuff is. I'm excited to try the trout (which I'll actually eat).

    Feedback

    I thought the whole experience was actually pretty seamless...

  • Really delicious smoked fish. You can tell it is high quality the moment you open the can. Canned fish is currently my main source of animal protein, but it's always a bit of a struggle to know if what you are buying is trustworthy from an environmental standpoint. I appreciate that Fishwife's focus on ethics and sustainability. It also doesn't hurt that the branding is so spot on. Love the artwork on the packaging.

    Feedback

    Fish options are limited for now. Would love to see mackerel and a non-albacore tuna option. I tend to choose skipjack or yellowfin over albacore in order to minimize mercury intake.

  • Incredible taste, amazing packaging/design, and inspired by the brand ethos to make fish cute + sustainably sourced.

    Friends with Fishwife