Everlane reviews and discussion

4.1

84% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Durable denim construction
  • Soft, luxurious cashmere
  • Minimalist, timeless aesthetics
  • Comfortable everyday pants
  • Inconsistent sizing accuracy
  • Boxy, unflattering silhouettes
  • Thin, shrink‑prone cotton tees
  • Narrow, blister‑prone footwear

Everlane proves a reliable source for well-made basics, according to reviews of Everlane, with standouts like Way‑High Jeans, Classic/Cheeky denim, cashmere, alpaca sweaters, and utility/barrel pants that hold up and anchor capsule wardrobes. Reviews also fault inconsistent sizing and boxy, unflattering cuts, variable fabric quality (thin tees, shrinking/pilling), and a drift from earlier simplicity—plus ethics concerns (union-busting) and limited size inclusivity—making the brand hit-or-miss depending on the piece.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

752 reviews and posts

  • Sustainability is built into this brand. The materials, the styles/cuts and colors are all classic and long-lasting. I love the items I have from Everlane (a few pairs of jeans, a sweater, and a button down) but they are definitely “investment pieces” perfect for a capsule wardrobe. In order to make high quality, eco-conscious clothing, the price needs to reflect that. I’m a fan of keeping it simple and opting for timeless classics so I felt good about my purchases.

    Feedback

    Limited extended sizing, including petite. This seems like a basic thing for a reputable clothing company to offer.

  • I had a great experience with the customer service at the Everlane store. I love the brand’a mission, and it is important to me to support clothing brands that pay livable wages to their employees. Unfortunately, I am between sizes in their clothing, and wasn’t able to purchase any of their pants. I did purchase a t-shirt which is very soft, comfortable and flattering. I hope to one day be able to try more of their clothing.

    Feedback

    I think the pant sizing could use some improving, as I couldn’t make any work for myself. One size up was way too big, and one size down was uncomfortably small.

  • Quality products and feels ‘made to last’ Sizing is not consistent

  • A friend of mine gave me two pairs of jeans from Everlane that didn't fit her and I was pleasantly surprised to see it had fit me. The no-stretch denim is really great and I'm excited to see how they wear over time.

    Feedback

    The sizing is off. I wear a size up than my typical size and while it's not uncommon, but it can be frustrating when purchasing from a company online because no one wants to have to go through the process of returning clothes online.

  • My favourite thing about everlane is that everything fits true to size and as expected. Great quality for the price - my go-to for all basics.

  • Love their stance on sustainability but clothes can be better. White v neck was see through and thin. I purchased the black ankle jean and it still smells like iron even though I’ve had it for 3 years and wash it frequently. Faded significantly after the first wash.

    Feedback

    Clothing quality and fit

  • I like the mission but a few of their items run small on me. Not very size inclusive.

  • Prices are reasonable for basics

    Feedback

    The cuts are all quite boxy but a great place for basics. Love their shoes. I have boots and slippers.

  • Overall I felt Everlane has great fabric and quality of clothing & accessories. I appreciate the price breakdowns on their website indicating how much the actual cost of labor was & the retail markup price. The return and exchange process is very easy and customer service is very understanding and quick!

    Feedback

    One of my concerns is the sizing. I have noticed they tend to run small so I would recommend ordering 1 piece at a time or visit them in-person to ensure you select your appropriate size.

  • Everlane creates high-quality clothing and accessories at reasonable price points. I enjoy the timeless style of many of the items I have purchased from Everlane. They will stand the test of time and not lose their appeal as trends fade. The footwear I have purchased is very supportive and comfortable. Considering the company doesn't specialize in footwear, I'm very surprised how my feet don't feel any pain wearing Everlane shoes (I have some foot issues). I typically purchase linen and cashmere items from Everlane and I'm very happy with the quality of the material. The cashmere has very minor pilling after countless wears (I practically lived in my recycled cashmere mock turtleneck sweaters this past winter). The cashmere socks feel like walking on a cloud; very luxurious at an affordable price point. The linen items I have purchased wash and wear very well. I was worried about significant shrinking, but there was none. Customer service is always easy to deal with. I've only ever had one issue with a product that arrived damaged, and they provided me with reasonable options to solve the problem.

    Feedback

    More linen and cashmere items! Especially for me. I would love to purchase my husband some linen shorts and shirts for summer, but unfortunately haven't come across any on their site. I think a rewards program and email notification/subscription system would be great customer service initiatives.

  • Love love love. Everlane is always where I check first if I need another piece in my wardrobe! Their ethics, sustainability and value are on point! Also the sales are 🔥.

    Feedback

    More underwear in fun colors!

  • I love the quality of Everlane clothing. The T-shirt is especially great - a perfect fit on me - I'm petite so the length and sleeves being perfect is a big deal!

  • I find myself gravitating towards my Everlane pieces on a regular basis. I appreciate their philosophy on transparency.

    Feedback

    I've tried every jean cut and always run into the same problem: too tight initially then become too loose at the thighs and butt.

  • I can only speak about their backpacks. I've owned three in the past 10 years. Using them daily. They are high quality and work well to hold all the items I need daily.

  • Love their pant quality and cashmere. Those are the only items I have tried or thrifted. I like the simplicity of the clothing and the material they use.

  • Good quality and classic silhouettes that feel timeless and not too trendy.

    Feedback

    More variation in styles and colors

  • I have several things from cashmere sweaters to pants from Everlane and everything is really high quality and pleasant to use every day.

  • Everlane products or so high quality! Returns are easy and you get refunded quickly.

  • I love buying staple pieces from them and have been purchasing from them for years. I always try to hold off on sales for basic tops because the cost of basic tops seems steep. I love how I can return through happy returns but I hate having store credit because they charge a shipping label fee. It is my least favorite part of the experience and makes me hesitate on purchasing items I'm unsure about.

    Feedback

    Get rid of shipping label fee

  • Absolutely gorgeous, well made simple pieces that stand the test of time and wear

    Feedback

    The prices can be a little steep and shipping to the UK is quite pricey