4.6
94% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Tony's Chocolonely
Tony's Chocolonely reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Creamy, luxurious mouthfeel chocolate
- Inventive, memorable flavor lineup
- Chunky, satisfying bar format
- Ethical, mission-driven sourcing
- Overly sweet chocolate profiles
- Thick, hard-to-break pieces
- Inconsistent caramel texture hardness
- Limited higher-cacao dark options
Tony’s Chocolonely earns strong reviews for rich, creamy chocolate, inventive flavors like Milk Caramel Sea Salt, Dark Almond Sea Salt, and Dark Milk Pretzel Toffee, plus mission-driven, fair-trade sourcing. Reviews also flag drawbacks: some bars taste overly sweet or bland to dark‑chocolate loyalists, the thick, uneven pieces are hard to break and share, and concerns appear about heavy metals in certain dark varieties and salt intensity in caramel bars.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
1,927 reviews and posts
Affordabe price, great mission, awesome and declious flavors. I love Tony's and buy it whenever I see it.
great chocolate - cut in different shapes so that it's fun to snack on
4y ago
Yum!! I love to nibble on dark chocolate and have tried my fair share of different brands. Tony's is some of the best tasting and love the thickness of it. The dark chocolate melts in your mouth. The packaging is also great, along with the mission of the company.
Feedback
More dark chocolate varieties!
The way I love this chocolate... if I see it, I'm buying it!
Feedback
More flavors! I was traveling internationally and saw some flavors that I'd never seen in the states (Chocolate Chip Cookie!) Would love to see more flavors stateside.
4y ago
My favorite chocolate bar. The salted caramel flavor was the one that converted me back to milk chocolate after only having dark for years.
Feedback
The way the chocolate is molded is semi annoying to break off in manageable pieces but it is half the fun though.
10/10 on taste. 10/10 on packaging.
First got this chocolate while traveling. They have great variety of flavors and cute packaging.
If you can find the purple bars (dark milk chocolate, pretzel, and toffee) STOCK UP. I was introduced to Tony's by a friend who brought over a skillet cookie (Heidi Swanson's recipe) as well as an extra bar of Tony's (perfect gift) and now it's the only chocolate I buy.
Feedback
It's hard for me to find the purple bars!!!
5/5 I love this chocolate. I am pretty picky when it comes to chocolate but this is the only milk chocolate I will buy. Others are way too sweet. Perfect for anything you need chocolate for. The foil it is wrapped in allows for east storage. I also like that they don’t use plastic wrappers in their chocolate.
Feedback
This brand is great, I haven’t ever visited their website or anything I always just pick it up at the grocery store. So maybe a QR code on the packaging to their website would be interesting.
Absolutely delicious chocolate in a good variety of flavors
Feedback
It's pricier than other chocolates, but based on their ingredient sourcing and quality I think it's worth it
Excellent chocolate, and I love the dairy-free options. I also like that it's available in a lot of places-- movie theaters, drug stores, grocery stores, etc.
Feedback
It would be nice to have some more flavor options!
My all time favorite chocolate. Deliciously rich & ethically produced. Literally the perfect combo. Sure, the price point is higher than a Hersey's bar but it isn't outrageous. 10/10 worth it and would recommend to a friend.
I love love love this chocolate! While it seems expensive for a bar of chocolate, the taste is amazing. The sea salt flavor is incredible and truly one of the best chocolates I've ever had. I always stock up when these are on sale at Whole Foods and I may genuinely never eat another brand of chocolate. Plus, the packaging is to die for and looks great on your counter or in a gift box.
Feedback
A lot of the flavors taste exactly the same and I wish they incorporated dark chocolate into more of their flavors.
Have tried multiple chocolate bars from this company and thought they were all really great! Also love their packaging! And their mission is amazing!!!
Feedback
Honestly nothing that I can think of
This chocolate is so wonderful! This is a staple in my house, especially for baking chocolate chip cookies. I’ve only had the classic flavors and these are definitely worth the money if you are looking for high quality chocolate.
THE BEST chocolate. fun packaging and great variations
4y ago
Amazing chocolate with an amazing mission. 10/10 recommend + read the wrapper.
YUM. That’s all I need to say. All the flavors are rich and also, original! Definitely not an average brand of chocolate
Feedback
Can we please get white chocolate without raspberries? :)
Great! Chocolate is solid, delicious, and definitely priced fairly. It doesn't get better than this.
It's just really good simple quality chocolate in adorable packaging. My current favorite of theirs is the milk chocolate wafer cookie. They're also actively avoiding slave and child labor which is absolutely fantastic and the wrappers are recyclable.
Feedback
I'd like to see more experimental flavors. I'd also love vegan "milk" chocolate options.