Thingtesting Logo

Tillamook

4.8 • 23 Reviews

Tillamook makes delicious cheeses, butter, and sour cream using traditional methods.

tillamook.comArrow up right
Shop Arrow up right
Tillamook Reviews

4.8

Tillamook earns strong reviews and decisively proves it is good: its sharp and extra sharp cheddars deliver full, tangy flavor and melt beautifully, and the ice cream is praised for rich, creamy textures and standout flavors like Marionberry Pie and Sea Salt Honeycomb Toffee. Reviews also flag inconsistencies—some ice cream flavors feel cheap with sparse mix-ins, butter underwhelms versus store alternatives, and microwave-prepped mac and cheese lacks optimal texture compared to oven baking.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

Photos

Articles

Reviews and Posts

View all 23

  • 10h ago

    I had higher expectations for this because it's something both my partner and I can agree on as well as waffle cone chunks in it. Overall it tasted more cheap to me than their regular vanilla or chocolate flavors. The waffle cone bits were also few and far between. I would not get this one again.

  • 1y ago

    Tillamook makes excellent quality cheese and other dairy items. I especially like their cheese and cream cheese. They both have such a rich taste that cannot be matched by competitors. The price tends to be a bit higher but worth it.

  • 3y ago

    I always put out a cheese plate when I am entertaining for the holidays; I like to use a variety of cheeses on it. One I use consistently is Tillamook's extra sharp white cheddar. It has a full flavor with a nice bite and pairs well, on a cracker, with jam or olives. I also like the unique flavor of their hickory smoked cheddar but that's a little harder to find in stores near me. I didn't know, until recently, that they also make ice cream so I'm looking for give that a try soon.

  • 3y ago

    This brand makes good ice cream that my family enjoys. I do like that this brand has better ingredients in their ice creams than that of some others. The taste is pretty good for their frozen treats as well.

View all 23 reviews

Alternatives

What is Tillamook?

Tillamook makes delicious cheeses, butter, and sour cream using traditional methods.

In their own words

Tillamook Shop