I've only tried the Fruit Butter Lip Mask from Seraphine, but I absolutely love it. It's a thicker formula, and really works to moisturize dry/chapped lips. I live in Boston, so I'm super picky about lip products because the climate can be so harsh. I actually really love this one! Packaging is beautiful too, and the product smells great! Highly recco. :) Love that they make clean, cruelty-free, and plant-based formulas, too.


