Salt and Straw reviews and discussion

4.6

93% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Ultra-creamy texture ice cream
  • Inventive seasonal flavor lineup
  • Aromatic freshly-made waffle cones
  • Impressive vegan flavor execution
  • Occasionally cloying sweetness levels
  • Hit-or-miss experimental flavors
  • Heavy, rich mouthfeel fatigue
  • Pints less vibrant than scoops

Salt & Straw earns largely enthusiastic reviews for richly creamy texture, inventive seasonal combinations, and standout classics like Sea Salt with Caramel Ribbons, Salted Malted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Chocolate Gooey Brownie, Honey Lavender, and Arbequina Olive Oil; the brand is good and often considered worth the line. Reviews also flag drawbacks: experimental flavors can be hit-or-miss or overly sweet/rich, some find hype outpaces taste, and pre-packed pints trail fresh scoops.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

123 reviews and posts

  • S&S ice cream is very good, it's creamy and their flavor combos are different then most places I've been. As with a lot of ice cream shops you can taste all of the flavors so if you know your getting something you will enjoy. I have had tried flavors I didn't like but I simply don't order those. For an extra $0.50 you can get a split scoop which allows you 2 flavors with our commiting to 2 full scoops. I love having that option. I've never been here with out waiting in line but it moves pretty quickly and I think it's worth the 10 minute wait.

  • I've tried the Chocolate Gooey Brownie (favorite!), Honey Lavender, and Freckled Mint Chocolate Chip (vegan option) at my local store. Picked up a couple cartons to share with friends during a potluck - everyone enjoyed!

  • When I first had Salt and Straw it was in Downtown Disney. Now I am addicted! It is by far the best ice cream I have ever had.

  • I wasn't inclined to like the ice-cream because of the long lines. But there are long lines for a reason. Sampling is possible with a little mini stainless spoon (not plastic). Great mouth feel and fun flavors. They were out of sugar cones and upgraded me free to waffle cones.

  • Salt and Straw is a staple in my ice cream repertoire. The texture is my favorite level of creamy and their flavors are so fun.

  • Worth the hype. S&S sells reliably delicious ice cream.... yes it is worth cueing in san francisco in the fog for. Smooth, creamy, interesting flavors. Recommend!

  • They make a lot of weird flavors that don't really hit for me. Every time a new seasonal flavor comes out, I think how promising the descriptions sound but most of the time it ends up being a bust. But their basics are all solid. Personal favorite is the salted malted chocolate chip cookie dough.

  • Salt and Straw is delicious and as someone based in LA, I can say that this ice cream shop is popular for good reason. The ingredients are high quality, but that also comes at a cost!

  • Love the fun flavors, delicious cones and great service at their shops

  • I love salt and straw. I can tell the cream content of the ice cream is high quality and the flavors are always so unique. It’s fun to experiment with the icecream flavors in different recipes.

  • Crazy quality ice-cream. I've ordered twice in the past weeks and it has been always delightful. I would definitely repeat whenever I can. My personal best is the mint chocolate chip one

  • an evil company that made a deal with the landlord of our dear local gelato place of 20yrs to evict them. if you support small businesses DO NOT BUY HERE

  • Lots of interesting flavors to try and visitors always love it - I’ve been several times! But, it’s a bit pricey so I’ve been exploring other options.

  • Salt and Straw is so good—there is a long list core flavors that are always available, and the rotating monthly flavors are reliably creative and delicious. I love that they partner with local businesses and always have vegan and gluten-free options available.

  • Inventive and exciting flavors that always hit the spot.

  • I love stopping by a salt and straw and getting to try their new flavors. I have always been so happy with the choice I make

  • This is actually my favorite ice cream shop in Los Angeles, I love all the unique flavors and quality of the ice cream. My favorite flavors are the lavender as well as the chocolate ganache almond ice cream

  • Love the Salt & Straw ice cream. I always taste the seasonal flavors but it's hard to beat their tried and true like Chocolate Gooey Brownie and Salted Caramel.