Milk Bar reviews and discussion

Obsessed with their cornflake marshmallow cookie dough that you can make at home. INSANELY GOOD. Spendy but...omg... Just so good

DO NOT BELIEVE THEIR HYPE ABOUT DELIVERY. I ordered two cakes about a week before the date they needed to be at the location of my son's birthday party (30 guests), I had told his girlfriend I had the dessert covered. First, they use UPS, a known disaster for getting packages on time when there is a deadline. Most of their promo say FedX, not in my case. Second, they require a signature for delivery. Just what you want the hostess to have to schedule her day around waiting for a delivery. Third, the package has been at the UPS processing location since 7:00 am, it is now 7:00 pm no cakes. Go on line to complain and the auto response gives you FAQ's which for the first time state that they recommend ordering for 3 days before an event. Not once when you place an order do they state that or that they require a signature. Thanks Milk Bar, there are 30 people at a birthday party with no birthday cake. NEVER AGAIN.

The cookies tasted uncooked and soggy. The flavor was sweet but just not really pronounced.

I tried the confetti cake balls and I loved them, they were soft and not dry at all. It wasn’t too sweet either. I would definitely get some more of those.

Milkbar gives off a pretentious vibe, and without good reason — with a location here in LA, I've stopped in to get these items fresh (they were not good!). I can't fathom how bad they must be when shipped elsewhere in the United States.

I bought a birthday cake for my birthday and Oh My God! I'll do it again every year. Shopping was easy and picking up my order was even easier.

Who doesn't love the delicious taste of this product? I have purchased a few everyone had loved the Milkbar products

A great surprise for friends and family for special occasions!

Great branding, but taste of the cake was just okay. The cake balls were my favorite.

I love the milk bar cake and cake balls. They are amongst some of my favorite desserts and I could eat them daily.

This was the cake of my dreams. Seriously. This is the experience I think of when I think of birthday/funfetti cake, the quintessential one. And TBH, I work in the baked goods eComm space and also buy a lot of cakes, the pricing is actually pretty good.

Milk Bar Pie is Amazing! It is on the sweeter side but it's delicious along with any soft serve.

I like Milk Bar products, but they are so overly sweet and over priced. I only get for special occasions.

The concept and packaging is cute but the cookies are too sweet for me. I would rather spend money on having local cookies delivered to the recipient than pay to have Milkbar delivered.

I’ve heard a lot of hype about Milk Bar and finally caved into ordering some of their treats after watching a Netflix documentary on the owner. The items I tried (cookie sampler and birthday cake) were average at best, especially for the premium price. I found them to be overwhelming sweet with a generic taste. These would do if I have a major sugar craving, but there are other brands and local bakeries that provide higher quality with a more affordable price.

Milk Bar makes as a great gift item and a fun way to celebrate your birthday in spirit. The truffle balls are my favorite product because they give me this assessment of enjoying the brands products without overindulging

I didn’t think a cake ball truffle could be that good but oh my these are amazing ! I love getting their products at target and Whole Foods and the added fun of visiting a store in person.

I have only had the birthday cake flavor of products (cake and the truffles) and I am a little biased because birthday cake is my absolute favorite. It was so delicious and the truffles are the perfect consistency. Highly recommend for an occasion but a little expensive for a casual dessert.

I'm lucky to live within walking distance of a Milkbar store and usually treat myself to some cereal milk soft serve a few times each summer as well as some birthday cake truffles on, you guessed it, my birthday. Everything they make onsite is undeniably delicious and very much worth the price.

Have had the cookies a few times. Once purchased for myself and gifted several times. Every time I receive them as a gift now I am eager to give them away. They’re so mediocre which is so disappointed because I love the real thing. These cookies are dry, crumbly, and borderline taste stale. I am surprised this comes from Milkbar. Packaging is fun though. The tin I’ve received at least 5 times as a gift is always nice.