Mac Cosmetics reviews and discussion

4.1

84% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Iconic lipsticks, saturated color payoff
  • Long-wearing eyeshadows, smooth blending
  • Reliable fix+ setting spray performance
  • Durable paint pots, enduring pigmentation
  • Heavy foundations, cakey finish risk
  • Sticky lip gloss texture complaints
  • Drying liquid lipstick formulation issues
  • Inconvenient packaging, missing foundation pump

Mac Cosmetics earns strong reviews as a dependable, pro-grade staple with standout lipsticks, eyeshadows, and the cult-favorite Fix+ setting spray, though some find foundations heavy or hard to shade-match. Reviews also flag inconsistent innovation, sticky Lipglass, drying or patchy lipstick formulas for some, brush durability issues, and a few packaging missteps—useful caveats if you prefer breathable bases or fuss-free components.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

74 reviews and posts

  • I just got the new lip & cheek mouse in Velvet Teddy 2 and I am obsessed. As someone who has not tended to wear lipstick I really feel comfortable wearing this. It has a really plush almost powdery soft feel to it and has a blurring effect which is so pretty. Velvet Teddy 2 is the most perfect "your lips but better" shade.

  • The MAC lipstick is a makeup staple known for its rich pigmentation and wide range of shades to suit every style and skin tone. Its creamy texture glides on smoothly, providing intense color payoff with just one swipe. Many finishes are available — from matte to satin to gloss — so you can choose the perfect look for any occasion. The formula feels comfortable on the lips and doesn’t dry them out, making it easy to wear throughout the day. The sleek packaging adds a classic touch to your makeup collection. Overall, it’s a reliable, high‑quality lipstick that delivers bold, beautiful color every time.

  • I love MAC liquid eyeshadow line! It is so easy to apply and blend even with your fingertips. It goes on smoothly and evenly, there are no weird uneven patches. This eyeshadow stays on all day long and doesn’t smudge or crease. It also feels comfortable on my skin without stickiness or dryness.

    Received a free product from Mac Cosmetics
  • This eyeliner gives a good pigment and is easy to smudge if you’re going for a smoky eye effect. It is meant to last 24HR but for me it has lasted way longer. I have the shade vintage teddy and it gives a very nice brown color to my waterline and the perfect smoky eye look.

    Received a free product from Mac Cosmetics
  • One thing that I love about this spray is that it’s alcohol free so I feel it’s better for your skin. It does offer a matte look which i like because I have oily skin. I would say it does make my face feel a little more dry than i’d like but it is a matte setting spray so that’s expected. It made my makeup last the whole day!

    Received a free product from Mac Cosmetics
  • I have a mini lipstick from MAC Cosmetics. I think it is a fine enough product but you don't get very much for the price and it wasn't available in a lot of colors. The color I do have is an unusual color though so I think it was worth purchasing.

  • I think this is very similar to the Glossier perfecting skin tint but if it actually had some coverage. This formula is very “watery” and lightweight and gives off a nice dewy look finish. I think this is a good option if you’re a fan of lightweight to medium coverage and prefer that natural glowy, your skin but better look. It doesn’t feel very drying and I haven’t experienced any dry patches or piling. The only reason why I’m not obsessed with it is because of the packaging :/ the bottle makes application messy and not as convenient as it could be. Still I think it’s a good option for dewy, natural finishes.

  • I've only tried a few of the products from MAC and I'm not entirely impressed. The products seem expensive without really providing something extra to be worth the price. Their $30 mascara seems to be like most other mascara and is somewhat drying.

  • Although for some time I’ve doubted it, MAC is one of the best makeup brands and undoubtedly is of the strongest competitions. Their mascaras, lipsticks, blushes, complexion products, EVERY category performs beautifully!

  • The performance this brand delivers is top-notch. The lipsticks are a cult classics, eyeshadows are fantastic, and mascara the best yet. My only unliked product is the lash curler which doesn’t work on me and has ripped some lashed off.

  • I love the color pay off on this blush. It is nice for a powder blush and has a good sheen. The color was a little too coral for me, but I'd like to try other shades. Mac has other great products as well. I enjoy their setting spray.

  • Everything about these products screams luxe. The Stack mascara gives length and volume without clumping, and the eyeshadows blend like a dream. The lipstick feels rich and pigmented, but be sure to exfoliate—otherwise it clings to dry patches.

  • I love this product so much. It’s completely changed how my makeup looks. I’ve decanted it into mini spray bottle multiple times because I refuse to not have this with me when I travel. It melts and blends everything together so nicely!

  • “MAC powder and foundation are a flawless duo! The foundation provides smooth, even coverage, and the powder sets it perfectly without feeling heavy. My skin looks radiant all day—absolutely worth it and highly recommended.

  • All the products I have from MAC have been amazing quality! The fix plus, lipsticks, and eyelash curler have been amazing. Their products have great pigmentation and last all day. Their employees are great about finding your coloring as well.

  • MAC is where I started purchasing makeup products as an adolescent and their quality continues! MAC is such a good basic AND if you collect 7 empties they will give you a free lipstick (any color)!

  • Classic for a reason—pigmented but buildable, and the shades are so wearable. It blends easily without getting patchy and lasts through a full day. I always end up going back to these. The Glowy bluch has been my favorite.

  • MAC Russian Red is what I’m reviewing today. It’s a universal red blue shade supposedly good on everyone. Close. Very close. I’m still playing around with it, hoping it’ll work for me. We shall see. Apply carefully. It’s bold.

  • I have had quite a few of MAC products over the years. I currently have a customizable eyeshadow palette to put eyeshadow minis in, several eyeliners, a Mac paint pot in my skin color as an eyes primer and some lipsticks. I think the eyeshadows & eyeliners are definitely worth the money. They are highly pigmented and are long lasting, especially with the paint pot under them.

  • MAC lipsticks are iconic, and their color range is unbeatable, but some formulas feel drying over time. The foundations offer good coverage, but shade-matching can be tricky, especially with undertones. I do love the Ruby Roo 💄