Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

4.7

95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Velvety, ultra-creamy texture
  • Inventive, distinctive flavors
  • Plentiful, well-distributed mix-ins
  • Impressive dairy-free options
  • Inconsistent flavor execution
  • Occasionally icy, grainy texture
  • Some flavors overly sweet
  • Variable creaminess across pints

Jeni's Ice Creams earns rapturous reviews for rich, ultra‑creamy texture and inventive, true‑to‑label flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, confirming the brand is excellent. Reviews also flag downsides: pints are expensive, quality varies by flavor, and some report iciness or overly sweet/salty notes and occasional freezer burn from stores.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,842 reviews and posts

  • I’ve tasted it in the ice cream shop and flavors are great! It’s flavorful, a bit on the sweeter side though.

  • As an ice cream fanatic, I have tried basically alllllll the semi-luxury / small-batch / craft ice cream brands out there. Most still lack that satisfying over-the-top lick the lips UMPH that a fresh pint of Ben & Jerry's Phish Food packs. HOWEVER, not Jenny's. The flavors are present, the texture is creamy and rich, and the "stuff" is there - no need to go making tunnels in your pint to get the next crunch or swirl. Mint Chip and Brambleberry are my top choices but Salted Caramel is also always in my freezer.

  • how can you say no to an ice cream when it's getting closer to summer?! I really love this brand to my heart as it has so many flavors I wanted to try. Also like the texture and creamy flavor. I can't help catch one every time I see it.

  • First started out as a Jeni's fan when I went to their store. I didn't even know they sold their ice cream in groceries until recently! Love the unique flavors, love that they take risks. One of my favorite ice cream brands.

  • Dairy free ice cream that actually tastes good.

  • delicious unique flavors! My favorites are their Skillet Cinnamon Roll and their berry lavender. I feel like I often miss out on the seasonal and limited edition flavors; they rarely make it to grocery stores where I live. The ice cream has no shortage of mix-ins and has a creamy, decadent mouth feel.

  • I had the lavender ice cream. It was rich & very flavorful. I was going to Armitage but I see they’ve closed. I’ll go to wicker park this summer ♥️

  • This is the best ice cream flavor ever. I can't stress that enough the peanut butter to chocolate flake ratio is absolutely delicious. I love the ingredients that goes into this ice cream and that they offer dairy free options aswell.

  • Jeni's is one of my favorite brands of ice cream and has been for years. I am a fan of numerous flavors, but the Powdered Jelly Donut and the Almond Butter Brittle are two of my all time Jeni's flavors.

  • My first experience with Jeni's was in Nashville TN... and it was an unforgettable experience. The quality of this ice cream is apparent from the first taste. Jeni's takes ice cream to an entirely new level. Forget what you think you know... give Jeni's a taste and you will begin planning your next taste immediately.

  • Eating jeni's brambleberry crisp is a spiritual experience that everybody needs to have! You are paying a higher price because you are truly getting amazing quality ice cream in flavors you are not getting anywhere else.

  • I always have at least 2 pints in my freezer at a time. Their Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip hits every single craving. Clean and simple ingredients is an added bonus. 10/10.

  • Y’all!!! This ice cream is 10/10. I have not had a single bad flavor literally all of them are fantastic! It is super creamy and not super sweet! A little high price wise but 100% worth it.

  • I will go out of my way to buy this at the grocery store and I wish we had more flavors or even a shop in Seattle. I’ve visited shops in travels and they are so cute. I am tempted to order on live but I’m scared we will be away when they arrive and that might be a hassle, I typically do not buy perishables in the mail.

  • I was gifted this ice cream as a birthday gift, and the packaging was so exciting. Dry ICE!! my kids were blown away, and that was before we even tasted the ice cream. ITS DELCIOUS!

  • I absolutely LOVE this ice cream brand. Amazing flavors, fun packaging, and overall amazing. I highly recommend this to everyone!

  • There are so many of them. Unlike, B&J’s, these do have the feel good factor that you would love to end your day with. Or sometimes begin with (green tea flavor)

  • The joy of walking into Jeni’s with my two grandsons is priceless!! The quality of the amazing flavors is a treat to behold. These are trips to the ice cream parlor that are memorable from delightful beginning to the deliciously messy end. Juju