4.7
95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Jeni's Ice Creams
4.7 • 1,842 Reviews
•
Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Velvety, ultra-creamy texture
- Inventive, distinctive flavors
- Plentiful, well-distributed mix-ins
- Impressive dairy-free options
- Inconsistent flavor execution
- Occasionally icy, grainy texture
- Some flavors overly sweet
- Variable creaminess across pints
Jeni's Ice Creams earns rapturous reviews for rich, ultra‑creamy texture and inventive, true‑to‑label flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, confirming the brand is excellent. Reviews also flag downsides: pints are expensive, quality varies by flavor, and some report iciness or overly sweet/salty notes and occasional freezer burn from stores.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
1,842 reviews and posts
I adore this ice cream. Even as a dairy-consumer, their dairy free options are INCREDIBLE (I'm looking at you, Texas Sheetcake). I'm so glad Jeni's can be found nation-wide AND they ship (and ship quickly!).
Feedback
The churro ice cream texture isn't my fave! To me it feels like I'm eating wet newspaper.
Unique and yummy flavors with a good consistency.
Feedback
Price is too expensive
Great packaging. Unique flavors. High quality ingredients.
Feedback
Every once in a while you find a brown that truly gives you what you pay for and I feel like this is a great example. Jeni’s ice cream is delicious and taste like homemade ice cream. I recommend this to all my friends.
Very rich, creamy, luscious ice cream with fun, unique flavors. My favorite flavor is creme puff. I also love the relatively uncomplicated ingredient list. If it weren’t for the price, I would always buy this at the supermarket.
Feedback
I love this ice cream, but it comes at a high price.
4y ago
So expensive but high quality ice cream with super fun flavors, worth the money every once and a while.
Feedback
Some of the flavors are a little too sweet tasting.
Jeni's is one of my favorite ice cream brands. The texture is noticeably more rich and creamy compared to other brands at your supermarket. They're always putting out new and interesting flavors. You have to applaud them for putting out an Everything Bagel flavor that works! That's what I love about Jeni's - they're not afraid to take risks.
Feedback
Nothing, their ice cream is perfect.
4y ago
THE BEST! I don't live in a city with a Jeni's anymore and I really miss – especially Brambleberry and Ooey Gooey Butter Cake.
AMAZING and delicious! AN amazing experience WITH SEVERAL NON-DAIRY OPTIONS.
Feedback
more non-dairy flavors!
I've tried many flavors both in-store and at the grocery store. Really delicious, high quality, and interesting flavors.
I am in LOVEEEE with Jeni's! I frequently stop by their Chicago location any time I need a sweet pick me up.
Fantastic icecream, really novel flavors.
Feedback
Price point is high, even for the category and when compared to similar brands. Difficult to justify
4y ago
I'm a fan of Jeni's, a midwestern ice cream chain (from OH) that makes delicious ice cream with seasonal flavors. Going to their shops in my area is always a treat. I like their brambleberry crisp and brown butter almond brittle!
Feedback
I'd love to see some limited edition flavors for a particular region, like using GA peaches for the southeast!
4y ago
Great ice cream, cute marketing, unique flavors.
Feedback
Little pricey but in line with typical artisan ice creameries.
Not every flavor is worth the price but they are all so delicious! The gooey butter cake is next level good and my personal favorite, but my local Whole Foods is consistently sold out of almost every flavor. I visited their store in Austin and was blown away by how many flavor choices there were and the diversity of their flavors. Definitely one of the best ice cream brands I have tried.
Feedback
Expensive for a pint of ice cream.
Jeni's is amazing! Best ice cream honestly if you like creative flavors. I love trying their new flavors--my favorite is the birthday cake one!
Feedback
Wish they were in more stores!
4y ago
These are very good and have a wide variety of unique flavors!
Amazing flavors! Brown Butter Almond Brittle is my favorite. It’s indulgent and delicious.
Feedback
Quite expensive for a pint of ice cream and I can only find a few flavors in my grocery stores.
The creamiest and most delicious ice cream out there. I always look for Jeni’s ice cream to pair with homemade baked goods because the quality compliments the baking so nicely. They have a range of unique, non traditional flavors and the classics which I appreciate. Their Gooey Butter Cake is my all time favorite.
Best ice cream Ive ever had. Went to their store in Durham and I’ve recommended to just about everyone I know to buy it at their local grocer.
4y ago
Delicious! Love Jeni's