Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

4.7

95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Velvety, ultra-creamy texture
  • Inventive, distinctive flavors
  • Plentiful, well-distributed mix-ins
  • Impressive dairy-free options
  • Inconsistent flavor execution
  • Occasionally icy, grainy texture
  • Some flavors overly sweet
  • Variable creaminess across pints

Jeni's Ice Creams earns rapturous reviews for rich, ultra‑creamy texture and inventive, true‑to‑label flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, confirming the brand is excellent. Reviews also flag downsides: pints are expensive, quality varies by flavor, and some report iciness or overly sweet/salty notes and occasional freezer burn from stores.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,842 reviews and posts

  • Jeni's has become my new favorite ice cream. It is made with clean, fresh ingredients, and has a great taste and mouth feel. Lowering the price wouldn't hurt, but it's still a great product.

  • Not to sweet, delicious and creamy, i got this from a friend recommendation. Worth the shipping to my house. It was still frozen when it arrive it was amazing the flavors were unique.

  • This ice cream is super good. I am holding out to try the Everything Bagel flavor but I love buying this as a treat for myself.

  • I’ve only ever been to their stores but their flavors are unmatched! Very fun high end ice cream and they take themselves less seriously than a van lueewen (that’s a good thing…it’s ice cream!).

  • For a treat, it’s good! However, I think sometimes these luxury brands try to look like nicer, guilt-free alternatives. It’s still ice cream. The flavors are nice though.

  • The experience of entering a Jeni's store is a feast for all senses. I have visited them in multiple cities and it is always a delight. Additionally, I have picked up a few pints from Whole Foods and the product is just as tasty. Only missing the fresh waffle cones you get at a physical location!

  • the pints are nowhere near as good an experience as an in-store visit, but the flavors are still amazing.

  • Incredibly delicious but also incredibly expensive. Worth a pint as a treat every once in a while, but not too frequently.

  • Great ice cream and some really unique flavors! Love the branding too. Really good flavors for restrictive diets.

    Feedback

    It’s definitely expensive, so not the type of ice cream I would buy every trip to the store but a good treat

  • Delicious ice cream. Don’t love the use of palm oil but like how most flavors are gluten free including the cake flavors.

  • look, i live next to a jeni's and it's great. i'm all for supporting local businesses and all that, but they just don't do it as good as jeni's. and i come from a family that slams down ice cream pints, and this still makes the list. wholly recommend.

    Feedback

    obviously not all flavors are hits. also, it's a bit pricier but justifiably so.

  • Jeni's has really unique flavors that actually taste incredible. My favorite thing, though, is Jeni's giftable ice cream — you can send packs of 4-6+ pints of ice cream as a gift for a reasonable price that anyone would love. I've used Jeni's as a gift often (and have received it as well) and it comes packaged well and always is a hit.

    Feedback

    None!

  • Jeni's has many unique flavors and I'm thrilled I can find them at the grocery store in addition to scoop shops. You can taste the quality ingredients and I enjoy discovering combinations that I wouldn't necessarily try unless they were already put together.

  • This is a hometown favorite! I love their innovation and creative flavors and of course they taste amazing. This brand is definitely worth the SPLURGE!

    Feedback

    a little expensive, but you really cant get what they offer from anyone else!

    Influencer for Jeni's Ice Creams
  • The butter mint ice cream is the best ice cream I’ve ever tried in my life- I would eat it daily if I could.

    Feedback

    I wish it was available in more stores- I’ve never found the butter mint flavor available outside of the East coast!

  • I've tried a variety of flavors from Jeni's. Most are excellent, while others are just ok. The "just ok" ones tend to be the limited editions in my opinion.

    Feedback

    Less is more. When there are too many add-in's it complicates the taste.

  • I tried several flavors from this brand but I always found it too sweet compared to other ice creams I've had. Very creamy texture and interesting flavors, but very sweet.

    Feedback

    Pricey.

  • Great for a pre-packaged pint of ice cream. Cute design, yummy taste. It's not my favorite on the market, but it always gets the job done. And they definitely have an intriguing selection of flavors.

    Feedback

    Do not, I repeat do not, try the Everything Bagel flavor. Life is too short. Stick with the Gooey Butter Cake.

  • I love jeni’s!! I love visiting their shops whenever I’m in a city that has them but when I’m not - I’m so happy I can just pick up a pint! I love their innovative flavors. It never feels too sweet or overpowering. The perfect balance of whatever the flavor is. Gooey butter cake is a go to!

    Feedback

    Unfortunately, a few times I’ve picked up pints they have been severely freezer burned to the point where the ice cream no longer tastes good. Not sure if this is a distributor problem, or the stores that sell the pints but there is nothing more disappointing than picking up a pint and it tasting completely off its normal deliciousness!

  • Im not an ice cream lover, but this its my exception to the rule

    Feedback

    Always try a different flavor, trust me it's worth it Also we need this in Miami

    Client