4.1
78% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Home Dough
4.1 • 52 Reviews
•
Home Dough reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Buttery flavor
- Convenient single-serve format
- Bakery-like texture
- Organic ingredient profile
- Excessive packaging waste
- Inconsistent baking times
- Non-resealable packaging
- Overly oily texture
Home Dough proves to be a workable, tasty ready-to-bake cookie brand in reviews: customers say the cookies genuinely taste homemade and convenient, but many call out excessive packaging, inconsistent bake behavior (molasses ginger spreads thin), and a high per-cookie cost. Reviews praise buttery, bakery-like flavor and single-cookie convenience while warning buyers about uneven bake times between flavors and oily or overly buttery textures.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
52 reviews and posts
Okay, YUM! I got totally suckered into an Instagram ad to try Home Dough before they officially launched, and I've been slowly savoring these cookies! My favorite is the oatmeal toffee, though they're all delicious! Also, incredible branding, packaging, website, and photography. All around impressed with the launch!
Feedback
The molasses ginger spice cookie spread out a ton, which ended up being a yummy thin crispy cookie, but the look and texture was pretty different from the other 2.
4y ago
These cookies are so, so good and definitely taste gourmet. I love that they come ready-to-bake so that I can make one as opposed to an entire tray I'll eat in one day. Plus, they have gluten-free versions!
Feedback
More sustainable packaging would be great.
4y ago
I tried all three flavors - Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Toffee and Molasses Ginger Spice. These cookies were just okay - they’re good but I don’t see myself buying them again at this price point. Nothing blew me away about them.
Feedback
Decrease in price for sure. Also, resealable packaging.
4y ago
So easy, yummy, and a great treat!
Feedback
Mothing
4y ago
They're pretty darn good. Not excellent, but nice to have around. The oatmeal toffee flavor was my favorite. I've found they're pretty easy to burn, but that could honestly be user error and a finicky oven.
Feedback
This isn't really something that Home Dough can control, but I'm just not a huge fan of shipping frozen/refrigerated products. It just feels too wasteful. I'd buy these again in a heartbeat if my local grocer carried them, though.
4y ago
These cookies taste like a warm hug. The kind of hug that comes easily whenever you need it. Because these are kept frozen, it's easy to take 2 out to bake for that moment you just want something sweet. You don't have to worry about cooking the entire batch which is handy. I purchased the variety pack but I've only tried the chocolate chip and I'm really happy with them.
4y ago
Tasty & convenient!
Feedback
More sustainable packaging & shipping materials.
4y ago
Tastes like you baked it from scratch. Good ingredients (organic, no preservatives). The Molasses cookies taste exactly like ones my Nana used to make (sorry,Nan). Soooooooo droolworthy!
Feedback
A little $$ to be able to enjoy them on the regular.
4y ago
My toddler (and me, let’s be honest) is obsessed with cookies. I can’t keep up with making my own homemade dough so Home Dough is the answer! We tried all three kids and my favorite was the chocolate chip and the oatmeal toffee a close second (particularly good the next morning dipped in coffee). We ordered and they arrived SO fast and I love the packaging. Such a delight to know a warm cookie is only 15 minutes away.
Feedback
Everyone’s oven is different. I overcooked the first batch and on the next one, dropped the temp a bit and the time and they were perfect. Just a note to watch and smell instead of just following the packaging instructions.
4y ago
The cookies arrived quickly. The packaging was easy to fit in the freezer. The cookies cook up thin and with a crunch. Great quality ingredients. My family said, "they taste buttery."
Feedback
I don't always want a thin crisp cookie, but for when I do, the convenience and quality of this cookie are great. I'm not sure I would pay the regular price, however.
4y ago
Home Dough has made baking delicious cookies just that much easier. They look and taste just like if I made them following a recipe. I've baked these cookies 5 nights in a row. I need help.
Devin C works for Home Dough4y ago