Home Dough

Bakery

Frozen Foods

Food

This is the best take-and-bake cookie dough I've had. I particularly love the Oatmeal Toffee cookies. However, they should make the bag resealable. Also, I used to buy these at my local Foxtrot when I lived in Chicago, but I haven't seen them in stores anywhere in NYC.

From a logistics perspective it might make sense to make the bags resealable. Also I'd include 12 cookies in each bag versus 8 which is a bit of an awkward number. The barrier to entry to trying them is really high with the cost being $54 for the three bags and a total of 24 cookie balls. 

I enjoyed them and glad I got to try them but I probably wouldn't order them again unless I got more cookie balls for the price so it was more of a true bulk order versus smaller bags for that money which is more for personal use. 

The cookies are packaged in a smaller box and that sits inside a larger box that is insulated with temper packs. The bags themselves are a bit smaller than I thought they'd be and they hold eight cookies. We put one of each kind in the oven to taste them all and they definitely have slightly different cooking times so if you are cooking them in a big batch just be aware. 

The Ginger spice cooks fastest and gets really flat and spread out so give enough space in between those ones. The Oatmeal toffee and cookie are both the same-ish size when fully cooked. Flavor-wise I liked Chocolate chip most, then Oatmeal toffee then Ginger spice. The Oatmeal toffee is really nice and chewy and feels a bit healthier than the other cookies. I look forward to making the rest of them. 

I don't know what the answer is, but the packaging needs WOOOORK! Also more flavors :-)

The idea is solid. Nobody's mad at ready-in-minutes pre-made frozen cookie dough hunks. But the unboxing experience is MADNESS. Sooo much disposable material, including a flimsily wrapped bag of dry ice that in my case spewed everywhere and stuck to my sink and created a weird steamy effect throughout my kitchen and cold-burned my hands... BUT the cookies. Were good! Not amazing, but good. Especially the chocolate chip, which I would say is a cut above many choco chip cookies I've had in my day, but certainly not good enough to justify the full-on slapstick Charlie Chaplin like episode I found myself in on a Wednesday afternooon... just... for... cookies.

More cookies per bag might make this feel like a better value, even if the price didn't drop much or at all per cookie.

I found the chocolate chip and oatmeal toffee cookies to be delicious. Molasses ginger wasn't my favorite, but this was also because its bake time appeared to be much shorter than the others. (Do not mix it with the others at bake at once if you get a variety pack!) The amount per bag was a little light for me, and price a bit steep. But they definitely taste a lot better than your grocery store cookie dough.

Honestly, the price is a little steep if you don't have a promo code. As good as the cookies are, I don't see myself spending that much money to ship cookie dough to my house. Otherwise, they are phenomenal cookies! If I could pick them up in a store - then we would have a problem because I would definitely be grabbing a bag every time I saw them.

The packaging is very fun. The cookies are SO EASY to make and they were the perfect dessert after dinner. How often do you have fresh baked, warm cookies right after dinner. Like, literally never. The flavor was super yummy. The cookies tasted like something you would get out of a bakery case. 

Got the variety pack. Cooked them all at the same time and seemed like they should cook at different heats/time even though they all list the same instructions. Molasses ones spread out super thin and the Oatmeal and Choc. chip stayed together and chewy.

These are really tasty cookies for pre-made dough but wasn't blown away and hard to justify the price personally with them not being better. Could be a fun one time gift for the right person.

These cookies are delicious!  They arrived quickly and in a well-insulated box.  It's nice that you can bake all, or just a few.  They bake quickly right out of the freezer.  The cookies do flatten out quite a bit, but the center is still pretty chewy.  Chocolate chip and oatmeal toffee were my favorites.  I also love that they have gluten free options.

Adding in another flavor or two would be great!

I was so ready to taste these cookies, as I am a huge fan of cookies in general (I was pretty obsessed with Crumbl last year) and the advertising and packaging for Home Dough claim they taste like they are homemade and will cause you to never want to eat another cookie again. Unfortunately, that was not the case with me, at least with most of the flavors.

Being a chocolate chip cookie fanatic, I tried that one first. And sadly, I was really disappointed. It felt like it had too much going on for my taste, as I prefer my chocolate chip cookies without oats and toffee. As of writing this, it's the only flavor that I have finished since I still enjoyed them enough to finish this flavor before trying the other two. I was also not a fan of the molasses ginger spice. These cookies flattened out so much, and the flavor was not to my liking at all. But I more or less expected that with this cookie. Finally, I tried the Oatmeal Toffee. I was expecting not to like it since my track record for oatmeal cookies is not great, but by some miracle, this is definitely my favorite cookie of the three! It doesn't really have the texture of oatmeal, which is the part of an oatmeal cookie I don't really like. It's more subtle, and I enjoyed the level of sweetness it has. Perhaps I like this cookie the most because I wasn't expecting anything from it, which is the opposite of my chocolate chip experience.

Overall these cookies were just okay. For me, they are not worth the price, but I can see why so many others enjoy them. One other thing I have not touched on yet is the design of this brand. I really do like it, as it has a nice modern logo and package design (as well as a super-cute website), but I can't really say it screams "this is from a mother's recipe and tastes homemade".

I would love to be able to buy these in stores!

These cookies blew me away. I am a teen baker and have worked on perfecting my own recipe for a while now. When I tried these, they mixed your classic chocolate chip cookie with a modern twist as well as making it organic! These are definitely worth a try!

Tips:

Don’t bake for longer than the package says! When these cookies sit, they continue to cook and create the perfect gooey center.

You can also use a large glass to circle the cookies when they come out of the oven to create perfect circular cookies.

Perfect as it is. Love the branding and packaging. More flavors please! 

These are wild. I baked them in the air fryer for 12 minutes at 325F. Absolute perfection. I will never be without these!! 10/10. 

About Home Dough