Coterie reviews and discussion

3.9

72% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Ultra-soft diaper material
  • Reliable overnight absorption
  • Accurate, comfortable sizing
  • Thick, durable wipes
  • Bulky diaper silhouette
  • Inconsistent leak prevention
  • Scratchy, fragile pant sides
  • Rash-triggering material reports

Coterie earns strong reviews for exceptionally soft, absorbent diapers and standout wipes that reduce leaks and blowouts for many, suggesting the brand works well—especially overnight and for sensitive skin—while others report rashes, occasional leaks, and fit issues once babies start walking. Reviews also praise accurate sizing, clean-feeling materials, and sleek, plain designs, but flag bulky cuts, fragile pant sides, mixed absorption experiences, and divisive performance versus mass brands.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

34 reviews and posts

  • I am excited to try Coterie for an extended period of time for diapers for my son - I love the soft feel and ease of shipments. However, I do feel that considering the price they are quite costly - so one point off for this.

    Verified purchase

  • Love this diaper and would highly recommend it to anyone! The fit was great and it's so soft. I was confident that what I was putting on my baby was safe and clean. We didn't have any issues with leaks or blowouts!

  • Loved using coterie diapers. They're so soft and SO absorbent. I was able to use them overnight with my newborn without any leaks or blowouts. I would highly recommend this brand to anyone and it even makes for a great gift!

  • I sent this to Coterie directly -- but a little public consumption never hurt for improving products. TLDR -- The Pant does not pull up without ripping open, do not buy. Dear Coterie -- We have been using Coterie for 26 months now. As soon as we tried them with our 2nd baby I knew the hype was real. You have a far superior diaper (AND wipe) product than anything out there. However, now that we are into the potty training stage with said 2nd baby, the PANT is an entirely different story. I highly highly recommend going back to the drawing board on this. It is nearly impossible to get them on my son without the sides pulling open. I've sized up and down, I've tried him laying down or standing up, no luck. I really wanted this to work because I love the ease of the subscription service. But alas, my order that arrived yesterday will be our last PANT order until there are changes made to it. I've wasted too many of them trying to make it work to stick with it. I know it's not easy getting it right for everyone, but I believe in y'all and will continue to sing your praises on the other products. Many thanks for 2 yrs of minimal leaks and blow outs. - AET

  • We used the diapers and later the pants, and definitely other diapers are toxic because our baby would have issues any time we would run out of Coterie and have to switch for a few days. They were great until our baby started walking, and then the fit was an issue, causing scratches and not staying in place. Switched to the pant version for a while and that was better but not the best non toxic option out there, the sides come undone and are scratchy and the fit is more long than wide. Great quality but price is a consideration.

  • These diapers were great, and the pants were ok. We found that most diapers really are toxic, and our baby would have skin issues any time we were out of the coterie diapers. However once our baby started walking they no longer fit well and stayed in place. Tried the pant version and they were ok, but not the best non toxic version out there. The sides come detached and are scratchy, and the fit is weird. The quality is there but the price is definitely a consideration.

  • I laughed at the Coterie ads on Instagram when I first saw them; “These diapers help parents sleep” seemed like a gimmick ad aimed at sleep-deprived parents. BUT THEN. We started using Coterie diapers just around the same time as we did sleep training. So franky, I don’t know what’s cause and correlation, but right now we’ve been lucky on the sleep front for a few months. I have zero reasons to mess with that, and so for now, I continue to be a huge fan despite the steep price tag. (We use Coterie diapers exclusively in the night to even out the cost a bit...) FYI: I took a close-up pic bc Coterie diapers are quite different in texture vs other diapers. They feel softer and have almost a textured feel to them. If you are figuring out what diapers to get I really recommend getting the Babylist “Diaper test kit” so you can test your way to your favorite!

  • Super soft and absorbent. Not too bulky. Haven’t had any blowouts since using these diapers. Sizing is accurate. Easy subscription management. Good wetness indicator. Only downside is that they are quite pricey.

  • If I could justify spending 50¢ on each one, I’d keep buying Coterie diapers. I really liked them—we used them for a month or so between size Newborn and size 1. They’re suuupppeeerrrr soft and work great. I love that they’re just plain white, and the wetness indicator works well. When we moved to size two, I switched to Millie Moon brand at Target, which is closer to 30¢ per. ***HOWEVER*** I’m completely 100% dedicated to Coterie wipes. They’re the best. We tried others but they can’t compare. The size is larger, the scent is simple and inoffensive, they feel gentle enough that I sometimes wipe his mouth or neck rolls :) with them. They get allllll the poop (by which I mean sometimes you still have to use 5. That’s just how infant poop works.) And my husband loves them because the pack doesn’t dry out EVEN if you leave the pack open at your changing table. And let me tell you, you WILL leave the pack open. Leave the lid flapped open on other brands and the entire pack will be dry and useless.

    Feedback

    The price, though high, seems justified. Because my baby was scheduled for an early c-section, I knew he was going to be premature and small (I had a medical complication); Coterie customer support worked with me to make a custom pack with their smallest size, which I really appreciated!!!

  • I got these diapers from a from and have to say they definitely are better quality than your average diaper. They're super soft, fit nicely, and pretty absorbent. Only con is pricing. It's pretty much twice as much as your best quality Huggies diaper. I think from ages NB to 4 months its smart to use Huggies and then 5 months onward Coterie makes sense as you use less diapers around that age and these are soft to sit in for a while. They're a nice to have but not a must.

  • Love the concept of this brand. Love the ease of the membership and the UI of the website and how I don't have to think about buying diapers. Also, the fit and material feel is so good for my baby. After having some skin rash issues with other brands Coterie's diapers always keep my baby's sensitive skin dry and never had a rash.

  • I got these in a sample pack and they have been the best diapers. They are also the most expensive diapers out there. Once you realize how many diapers you go through it’s hard to justify the cost. If I had unlimited funds, these would be the only ones I bought.

  • Coterie diapers are the one item I tell my pregnant friends about.

  • Coterie is a luxury clean diaper. They are soft, sustainable, hella absorbent, and made with the best materials. Their subscription service is costly but easy to manage, pause and cancel. Their wipes are the best wipes I have found for my baby: durable and massive. These are the wipes you want during a blowout or when you’ve got pizza grease all over your hand and your baby’s knees (why??!)

    Friends with Coterie
  • I received some diapers for my two month old as a gift and was pleased with them. Not sure how much better they are than any other diaper brand. They got the job done. ***update*** I have used Hello Bello diapers since writing the above review and did not notice any difference in softness or absorption. It seems like the high price tag for coterie is for people who really want the minimalist branding in their disposable baby poop sacks 🤡 pretty sure I’m not the target demo because I could never justify their prices.

  • the diapers are simply put the best on the market: super soft, amazing absorption, great fit... the wipes are also great, can't wait for them to launch a pull ups line... definitely a bit pricier than alternatives but totally worth it...

    Invested in Coterie
  • These diapers feel so luxe, super soft inside and out. I never had any leaks and minimal blow outs in these. I love that they have a plain design but the cut is a tiny bit bulky compared to, say, Huggies.

  • I know people rant and rave about Coterie - but I found they didn't quite live up to the hype. They are definitely soft! And they are absorbent. But I found them to be unreasonably overpriced for what they were, and too hard to purchase. I wanted to try a few before committing and couldn't pick them up at a local store (though I have noticed increased visibility as of recently). Ultimately I found an option that felt very comparable for us and at a better price.

  • THE BEST diapers and wipes. Wipes have slightly more ingredients than Water Wipes, but still have clean ingredients and are a lot thicker. In general we only use one Coterie wipe vs needing 2x Water Wipes. The diapers and pants are fantastic, at the hospital the nurses had never seen such nice diapers.

    Feedback

    I love the product; but unfortunately they don't treat their existing customers well. They have once increased shipping costs and once increased product costs, even for existing subscribers. I told them that other brands grandfather in the lower prices for existing subscription customers and it would help build brand loyalty, but my feedback was dismissed.

  • The diapers were SO SO SO soft.

    Feedback

    They're definitely a lot pricier than the larger brands.