Boy Smells reviews and discussion

4.4

90% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Distinctive, complex fragrance profiles
  • Chic, giftable minimalist packaging
  • Impressive scent throw performance
  • Long, even candle burn duration
  • Inconsistent burn quality tunneling
  • Occasional sooty, smoky extinguish
  • Variable scent strength projection
  • Rare vessel and label defects

Boy Smells earns largely positive reviews for richly unique, room‑filling scents—standouts include Hinoki Fantôme, Cashmere Kush, Cowboy Kush, Cedar Stack, LES, and Slow Burn—and sleek, giftable packaging. Reviews also flag inconsistencies: tunneling and uneven burns, occasional weak throw or over‑potent scents depending on fragrance, sooting/smoky snuff‑outs, rare vessel defects, and mixed longevity in perfumes, making scent selection and burn care essential.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

729 reviews and posts

  • Every scent is better than the last. It's the only candle brand I'll gift that doesn't feel like a lazy gift lol. I'm also going through their fragrances right now as I was gifted a sample kit for xmas, and may purchase a full size soon!

    Feedback

    Just wish it wasn't so $$$$. Makes it a "special occasion" candle, not an everyday burn.

  • I'm obsessed with the Italian Kush scent. I've never cared much for candles only because I'm particular about smell and I can't stand anything that comes across artificial — especially for the home. The scents are lovely and interesting. It's a simple enough package that it works with any interior and I've found that even a couple of the candles going at once is never too much because the notes tend to be really complementary.

    Feedback

    A good price for a high-quality candle that has differentiated scent profiles.

  • Any Boy Smells candle is a great budget friendly luxury candle. My favorite scent is the Purple Kush. It’s such a deep, beautiful scent. All the Boy Smells candles have a great throw and make my room smell fabulous. The packaging is also minimal but beautiful and sophisticated.

  • I love Boy Smells!! Their candles are to die for and their branding is gorgeous. I have not tried their fragrances on myself yet but I have smelled them in store and they also smell delightful. The candles burn evenly with good burn time and they also make a great gift. MY fave candle is Lanai but I also like the Kush line of fragrances,

  • Received a Boy Smells candle as a gift. We love candles in our household, probably have too many, and while I like the scent and the look and feel, this brand doesn't seem too different from the many other brand of candles we own. That said, still a solid candle and makes for a great gift.

    Feedback

    Probably not the intention of the brand, but if there was some added functionality could make the product more interesting (i.e. refillable service or if the container could be repurposed as a mug or something).

  • Love love love this queer-friendly candle brand. Their scents are delicious, tongue-in-cheek, and I they are my favorite candle company. They are reasonably priced (as luxury candles go), last long, have a great burn time, and truly love the scents (especially Slow Burn, Gardener, and Cowboy Kush).

  • I appreciate how the scents from these candles are not overpowering. You can leave them going in a small apartment without getting hit with a strong sent. For someone who gets headaches from candles these are amazing!

  • Really love this brand! Unique scent combinations with good throw for candles and staying power for perfumes. Scents can be hit or miss tho based on everyone's personal preferences. I tried The Fantôme and I just personally didn't like and was so strong it gave me a headache.

  • Amazing smells! My absolute favorite. The only reason I give 4 and not 5 is because I do struggle with their wicks. They tend to fall off center which can cause an uneven melt or struggle lighting the candle.

  • Not a huge fan of most candles but enjoyed this one. Received as a birthday gift and found the smell subtle enough that it was refreshing in the room.

    Feedback

    The wick mushroomed some after burning, quite annoying.

  • I have been loving these candles for years now. I really got interested in the brand because of the candle names and have been hooked ever since. They are on the pricier side but they smell amazing and the smell lingers long after it is blown out.

  • Unique scents, even burns, clean packaging, and proactive customer service. Personal favorite candle thus far: Hinoki Fantome.

  • Love the price point on these candles and the very clever names. I tested the Italian Kush candle, which smells lovely but is not overbaring. The burn time is great, especially for the price point.

    Feedback

    I would love to see more clean smells added.

  • While I was super stoked about the branding and the fragrance selection of Boy Smells, I had two candles (purchased at different times) explode! Quite the hazard.

    Feedback

    Stronger, tempered glass is a must.

  • Boy Smells boasts a diverse collection of candle smells but none particular stood out as a crowd favorite for me personally. But aside from smells, I love the minimalist design and it looks great in my apartment.

  • Love the scents, love the vessels - I use them long after the candle has run out for myriad reasons all over my house.

  • There hasn't been a single candle I've ordered that I don't become obsessed with. Every candle is amazing!