Maybelline reviews and discussion

4.4

92% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Smudge-resistant mascara performance
  • Lightweight, buildable lash formula
  • Bold, long-lasting lipstick pigment
  • Moisturizing, comfortable gloss texture
  • Drying long-wear lipstick feel
  • Gloss longevity limitations
  • Messy, product-heavy applicators
  • Transferring, rub-off foundation

Maybelline earns strong reviews as a reliable, effective drugstore mainstay, with mascaras like Lash Sensational Sky High and Great Lash delivering length, lift, and smudge-resistant wear, and lip staples like Super Stay Matte Ink offering bold, all‑day color. Reviewers note drawbacks including drying long-wear lipsticks without balm, gloss that fades and has a Play‑Doh‑like scent, occasional messy applicators or product buildup, limited shade range, and foundation transfer.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

25 reviews and posts

  • A classic! Always low price, always high quality. I am always content with my Maybelline products — they might not be revolutionary, but they always get the job done. From mascara to blush, I know I can always get a good product from them.

  • Maybelline is a reliable drug-store staple for everyday cosmetics. The lip sticks and eyebrow pencils are among my favorites to stock up regularly. Recently, I tried baby lips, which are a simple and easy blend of lip balm and lip gloss. I like the simplicity of this brand overall.

  • My favorite mascara! Would 100% recommend. Holds my lashes up and lasts long! Its super pigmented and the best mascara ever!

  • Very smooth lipstick love the colors especially the red my go to everytime it never fails highly recommend. Soft to touch and not hard to clean off is a plus for me.

  • For what it is, this is a great brand. Their products are super affordable, and a really good quality for what they're selling. Some of their products aren't really long lasting, and they don't have a big skin tone range.