4.4
92% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Maybelline
4.4 • 28 Reviews
•

4.4
92% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Maybelline impresses in reviews as a dependable, effective drugstore staple that delivers standout mascaras (Sky High, Great Lash) and long‑wear lips (Super Stay Matte Ink) with easy application and strong performance. Weaknesses emerge around limited shade range, occasional dryness in long‑wear lip formulas, some products lacking longevity, messy or product-heavy applicators, and foundation transfer—making it reliable for everyday looks but imperfect in finish and wear consistency.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
1y ago
I've been a huge fan of the super stay matte ink for a while now. It goes on so well, no cracking, doesn't dry out my lips, and stays on. I just bought the new one, the teddy tint, and I love the two I bought! I definitely need every shade, I swear. Great products that do what they claim.


1y ago
Maybelline is a reliable drug-store staple for everyday cosmetics. The lip sticks and eyebrow pencils are among my favorites to stock up regularly. Recently, I tried baby lips, which are a simple and easy blend of lip balm and lip gloss. I like the simplicity of this brand overall.

Maybelline is my go-to drugstore makeup brand, particularly for lip products. I love the Lifter Glosses — they're the most moisturizing lip gloss I've ever used. (But I could do without the Play-Doh-like scent.) The Superstay Vinyl Ink is a little more glam than I'm used to, but it provides great pigment if you want a truly opaque lip look. The brand's Instant Age Rewind Eraser is a new staple for me. The line seems to have good undertone options, and it's really easy to apply and blend. I do find that the fuzzy applicator gets messy quickly, though.


My favorite mascara! Would 100% recommend. Holds my lashes up and lasts long! Its super pigmented and the best mascara ever!

1y ago
Maybelline's Great Lash in Blackest Black is a solid mascara! I've been on the hunt recently for a mascara that does my lashes more justice, and this one holds up very well! I really like the applicator, and I personally bought the non-waterproof version of this mascara, but have found it still stays on very well.

Very smooth lipstick love the colors especially the red my go to everytime it never fails highly recommend. Soft to touch and not hard to clean off is a plus for me.

1y ago
My Experience with Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Lipstick I honestly can’t live without this lipstick! I wear it daily, and it’s incredibly long-lasting — it stays put for 24 hours until you remove it yourself. Even after eating or drinking, it doesn’t fade. I absolutely love it and always receive so many compliments when I wear it. I make sure to keep it stocked because it’s my all-time favorite lipstick. As a content creator based in the Netherlands, I would love to advertise this amazing product.

For what it is, this is a great brand. Their products are super affordable, and a really good quality for what they're selling. Some of their products aren't really long lasting, and they don't have a big skin tone range.