Maison Margiela REPLICA reviews and discussion

I know everybody loves this brand, but the scents just aren’t for me. I like the unisex element and the scent as memory concept, but the scents themselves are nothing special. They’re either too strong or too watered down, and they’re “crowd pleasers” in the sense that they’re just like pretty much any other brand of perfume that I’ve smelled over the years.

I finished my first bottle and got so many compliments. It's a lovely scent that has good staying power (lingers on clothes even post wear). I also love to layer it with other scents to switch things up. I'm now on my second bottle.

I really like these fragrances, I have had both beach walk and by the fireplace and think they are very unique and long lasting. I would definitely consider repurchasing one of their fragrances in the future.

best.fragrances. hands down. Every scent is a specific memory unlocked. IF you go to the department stores, you can also ask the workers at nordstrom to help you find the perfect layering pair of them.

smells divine, just like a fireplace without all of the smoke. burn time was great, dozens of hours, and love the simple brand design of the candle. expensive for sure, but the quality is worth it for me.

I got this as a gift and I feel so bad because I really wanted to like it but it literally smells like straight up tomatoes and dirt 😬 I thought the tomato wouldn’t be that bold but it is literally super overpowering. I guess it’s named accurately because it makes you feel like if you were in a tomato garden. No offense if those are the scents you’re into but this is a huge pass from me. I don’t vibe with it at all but I might try to figure out some way to layer it with another fragrance and make it tolerable.

This is the first truly luxury candle I've bought. I got it on sale for $33 which was a STEAL. The difference in quality between this and other candles I have is remarkable. Why did I not buy 4 more?! It burns very clean and even, and the vanilla scent of this candle is to die for.

Replica fragrances are next level. Every scent tells a story and feels luxe on skin. The longevity is impressive—it lingers softly throughout the day without fading. High-quality ingredients make these stand out as wearable memories, not just perfume. They are just a tad too expensive. The smell of lazy Sunday morning is so fresh but elegant and clean.

Esta fragancia de Maison Margiela Replica te transporta directo a la Costa Amalfitana con su aroma a naranja fresca y notas cítricas brillantes. Es ligera, refrescante y perfecta para el verano. Ideal si te encantan los perfumes que huelen a vacaciones y libertad. 🍊🌊

I purchased Replica's By the Fire perfume from Sephora, and I love it. It immediately became my signature scent. There's definitely a couple layers to it, it starts out much smokier and then fades to a bit sweeter throughout the day. I like their refill bottles as well, from a financial as well as a eco-friendly point of view.

It opens with a warm, boozy plum note that feels like you’re sipping something rich and indulgent on a sun-soaked patio. There’s this elegant blend of fruits and light woods that creates a smooth, almost creamy feeling as it settles on the skin. It’s sweet but not sticky, more of a warm sweetness that lingers in the air like the memory of a flirtatious afternoon. As it dries down, you get soft woods and musk that give it that skin-close sensuality. Longevity is moderate about 5 to 6 hours on me, but it wears more like a whisper than a shout, which fits the mood it’s going for. I wouldn’t call it a statement scent, but more of a vibe, sultry and laid-back, not trying too hard.

I love love love the coffee shop one. It’s like dessert plus coffee. I do not care for most others. A walk on the beach is boring. Jazz club smells like cigar smoke and I’m repulsed. I hate it. So, these are hit and miss.

The coziest scents!!! <3 I literally love each and every scent from this brand. They make you feel like your somewhere else whether thats at the beach, beside a fireplace or at a jazz club. So luxe, and the packaging is stunning, so you can use the bottle out as decor as well!

Great scents! By the fireplace has been a signature fall/winter scent for me through college and post-grad. I just wish that the ingredients were cleaner so I could spray it on my skin with no hormone disruptors.

Jazz Club is one of my favourite perfumes: it's woody, it's sweet, it's smoky. it's a perfect scent for cold fall days. Jazz Club is definitely unisex, both my husband and I wear it 🍂

I absolutely love the Replica Matcha meditation perfume! As someone who is passionate about matcha, this fragrance really hits the spot. The scent perfectly capture the essence of high-quality matcha. It has a calming, meditative quality that I find perfect for helping me relax and unwind. The fragrance is subtle, making it easy to wear throughout the day. If you're a fellow matcha lover, I highly recommend giving this perfume a try - it's a true delight for the senses

Long lasting & high quality! Get matcha meditation, smells incredible😍 Perfect for spring/summer

Under the Lemon Trees is such a beautiful, citrusy floral; amazing staying power and beautiful bottle. However, the cost is MUCH higher than I'd prefer as someone starting to get into fragrance!

Amazing range of perfume scents that are for male or females. There is a scent for every occasion

I bought the sampler from Sephora and each Maison Margiela REPLICA fragrance does indeed remind me of the moments they are inspired by. Music Festival especially.