Joydays reviews and discussion

4

66% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Low-glycemic formula, blood-sugar friendly
  • Soft-baked, chewy cookie texture
  • Colorful, eye-catching packaging
  • High-fiber, portion-controlled packs
  • Occasionally dry, cakey texture
  • Noticeable sweetener aftertaste
  • Small cookie size, scant quantity
  • Inconsistent, muted flavor intensity

Joydays earns largely positive reviews as a low-glycemic, low-sugar cookie that satisfies sweet cravings without spikes, with many comparing the soft-baked texture to Chewy Chips Ahoy and praising colorful packaging, generous chocolate chips, fiber, and portion-controlled packs. Reviews also flag downsides: frequent dryness or “healthy”/aftertaste notes, small cookie size, inconsistent texture, and polarizing flavors (notably peanut butter), making them a better-for-you alternative rather than a true classic cookie replacement.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

594 reviews and posts

  • I DID NOT LIKE ANYTHING ABOUT THIS COOKIE. MAYBE NOT USED TO EATING A HEALTHY COOKIE ESP LOW-SUGAR COOKIES.

    Verified purchase

  • Not great. Super small and expensive cookies

    Verified purchase

  • I tried the Chocolate Chip Cookies. Surprisingly, they tasted like the original Chips Ahoy cookies, which I'm not a big fan of. They don't have much flavor and aren't very sweet. I was hoping for a slightly sweeter, more chocolatey cookie.

    Verified purchase

  • Very good! Tasted a little bit like a chips ahoy but really just like normal cookie. And nice ingredient. Not bad macros but I would prefer more protein. Overall, really good.

    Verified purchase

  • I enjoyed the "bite" size and taste of the chocolate chip cookies. They also were fresh and nice as a snack. However; the cost of the box for the amount of servings is too high for me to purchase regularly. I would like to try the peanut butter too but they are sold out.

    Verified purchase

  • So delicious and only 1 gram of sugar is AMAZING. wish i could buy these in stores locally instead of having to order on amazon - thank goodness for 2 day shipping!

    Verified purchase

  • I brought the whole box with me to my annual visit to my family and we had them over our coffee. We enjoyed them more knowing they are the healthier options. It came in small packages of 2, so it is also conveneint to take them to school or work. I appreciate the opportunity to try them!

    Verified purchase

  • My daughter loves eating them. The taste is great, not too sweet, and the cookies are soft with chocolate chips, which is really nice. The only downside is that when ordering online, the box arrived deformed.

    Verified purchase

  • Adorable packaging, good sized cookie. I tried the chocolate chip: I found the texture dry and crumbly, and it didn't really scratch the "cookie" itch for me. It feels like a healthy, soft, granola bar vs. cookie. Nice to put in a lunchbox or in your bag so you reach for something healthy while on the go.

    Verified purchase

  • Although these cookies are not my preference, I think they are overall a decent cookie especially for anyone that is diabetic. They are low in sugar, and get the job done when you're craving a sweet treat,

    Verified purchase

  • Cookie Review: Delightful Bites of Joy I recently had the pleasure of trying a batch of cookies that were a delightful surprise. These small treats, perfectly sized for one or two bites, are a fantastic choice for those who love a quick indulgence without overdoing it. The first thing I noticed was their charming appearance—golden brown with a slightly rustic look. As I took my first bite, I was greeted by a satisfying crumble that added a delightful texture to each mouthful. While they were a bit crumbly, this only enhanced the experience, as it felt like I was enjoying something homemade and authentic. The flavor profile was impressive. Each cookie had a rich taste that balanced sweetness with just the right hint of saltiness. They were not overly sweet, making them perfect for pairing with a cup of tea or coffee. Overall, these cookies are a must-try for anyone looking for a quick, tasty treat. Their small size makes them perfect for sharing—or not! Whether you’re indulging solo or with friends, these cookies are sure to bring a smile to your face. Highly recommended!

    Verified purchase

  • love the taste of the cookies, yet they can melt quickly. I like that it got little sugar so now I can eat chocolate cookies and not worry

    Verified purchase

  • I wish that I liked these more than I did since they are low sugar. I tried the 3 flavors- chocolate chip, double chocolate, and peanut butter. Chocolate Chip was definitely my favorite. Overall, they were okay and I liked how soft they were. I would wonder how these would taste without the monk fruit and if they just kept in the allulose. I don't think allulose really has the same kind of aftertaste like the other natural sweeteners. Or if they only focused on minimizing the sugar without additional sweeteners besides something like date paste.

    Verified purchase

  • These cookies have a great texture and consistency. Personally i had difficult issues with getting the correct items when I ordered on Amazon. I received the wrong thing multiple times. These are great for someone watching sugar levels

    Verified purchase

  • I was so pleased with these chocolate chip cookies, and the impressive nutritional profile! The taste and texture was very reminiscent of chips ahoy soft baked cookies, but with the added benefit of fiber, and without the sugar and carbs. I love that they come pre-portioned, which makes them easy to take on the go and prevents me from overeating. I'm excited to try the other delicious flavors! 3 star because its too expensive

    Verified purchase

  • These cookies are great!! They aren't too sweet, but they have great flavors. I don't have blood sugar concerns, and I still enjoyed!

    Verified purchase

  • I purchased the chocolate chip Joydays and they were surprisingly delicious. They were very similar to the chips ahoy chewy chocolate chip but without the guilt. I would definitely purchase this product again.

    Verified purchase

  • These cookies were really yummy! Not the most amazing I've had - kind of an earthy taste - but good. Very chewy and moist, also like how they were pre-packaged

    Verified purchase

  • Yummy! Really hit the spot but are low cal and low carb

    Verified purchase

  • I LOVE Joydays, I would've never known about them if it wasn't for this campaign and they were so good! I love soft cookies and I'm usually not a fan of chocolate, but THESE?????? absolutely delicious, I was surprised! Very soft, not overly sweet, and just enough for a snack! I will definitely be buying again. The only thing was shipping from Amazon. Weirdly slow (I'm talking weeks) not sure what's up with that.

    Verified purchase