4.7
95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Jeni's Ice Creams
4.7 • 1,842 Reviews
•
Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Velvety, ultra-creamy texture
- Inventive, distinctive flavors
- Plentiful, well-distributed mix-ins
- Impressive dairy-free options
- Inconsistent flavor execution
- Occasionally icy, grainy texture
- Some flavors overly sweet
- Variable creaminess across pints
Jeni's Ice Creams earns rapturous reviews for rich, ultra‑creamy texture and inventive, true‑to‑label flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, confirming the brand is excellent. Reviews also flag downsides: pints are expensive, quality varies by flavor, and some report iciness or overly sweet/salty notes and occasional freezer burn from stores.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
1,842 reviews and posts
4y ago
The best ice cream you can buy in the grocery store! The flavors are always unique and delicious. My favorites are the Darkest Chocolate, Brambleberry Crisp and Everything Bagel.
4y ago
I love Jeni's ice cream! Jeni's Darkest Chocolate is my absolute favorite chocolate ice cream that I have ever had. I've tried a few flavors, but I always go back to the dark chocolate. If you're a fan of chocolate ice cream you have to try it. The consistency is so creamy and packed with flavor. Their pints are a little pricy, so it wouldn't be something I indulge in frequently, more of a treat for special occasions.
4y ago
One of my favorite reasons I lived in Atlanta was that I got to have Jeni's when ever I wanted. The flavors are soooo good. The goat cheese and cherry was my favorite flavor.
4y ago
I thought it was really high quality ice cream. The texture was super rich and creamy and the flavors were really unique.
Feedback
The price point is a little high but aside from that not much needs improvement
4y ago
I mean, it's delicious, but very rich and indulgent and not the type of thing you can eat more than a couple bites of.
Feedback
Some flavors are SO over indulgent and packed with things it's hard to even enjoy a bite.
4y ago
Overall it’s amazing and yummy!
Feedback
It’s quite expensive but overall really good tasting ice cream. I wish they had more dairy free options.
4y ago
Jennis is the best ice cream you will ever experience. Worth every penny.
4y ago
Use to live in Nashville and Jennis is a STABLE! So delicious and always packed! So glad they sell these in the grocery store now.
Feedback
Everyone knows that best jennis flavor is Goat Cheese and Cherries. You haven’t had Jennis until you’ve had this flavor, so it needs to be sold in stores too!!
4y ago
We have a few Jenis where I live and I’ve been quite a few times and I have also tried their packaged icecream, and I have to say, they are both delicious!! They have some interesting flavor options, and it’s so creamy. Every time I’ve been there the service has been so welcoming and kind!
Feedback
Wish there was a little more variety in the flavors!
4y ago
A little pricey but the flavors are immaculate and worth it
4y ago
The Blackout Chocolate Cake Ice Cream is incredible? my favorite pint available at the grocery store
4y ago
Jeni’s is my favorite ice cream. They have great packaging, a fun loyalty program, and an expensive-but-great club program (4 pints shipped every 3 months, i believe, and comes with specialty ice cream spoons). They also have a range of creative flavors that are actually GOOD instead of crazy flavors i would only want to try once. Brambleberry crisp and brown butter almond brittle are the best.
4y ago
Tried my first jeni’s ice cream in town and around the corner from me. Very interesting flavors and creamy taste.
Feedback
Nothing I can think of!
4y ago
Jeni’s is the best. I am so lucky to live in Columbus where it all started. It is my favorite treat - the bramble berry crisp is a must try!
Feedback
Expensive, but worth it!
4y ago
Love the unique flavors and the innovation the brand constantly exemplifies
Feedback
Increase exposure by entering more retail spaces!
4y ago
So yummy
Feedback
More flavor options
4y ago
I love Jeni's Ice Cream! The only reason I took a point off is because of their pricing.
Feedback
I think they should streamline their pricing of the to-do pints. Publix and Fresh Market, just down the road from Jeni's, sell the pints for $7.99. Jeni's Ice Cream locations sell the same product for $12.99. I find that excessive.
4y ago
Jeni’s is like eating a pint of heaven. My favorite flavor is Cream Puff! The texture and flavor are perfect. You get the softness and creaminess of a cream puff, combined with the ice cold bite of an ice cream. It’s perfect.
Feedback
Nothing to improve here! Jeni’s is one of my favorite ice creams!
4y ago
Excellent taste. We have a shop in our building. Great quality. Fun flavors to taste.
Feedback
Pricey.
4y ago
Jeni’s is absolutely amazing. Their brick and mortar stores are always a treat and the ice cream in grocery stores never fail to impress
Feedback
Sell the waffle cones in stores!