Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

Good but expensive, If you are wanting on a special say or occasion, 2 day shipping doesn't mean you will get it quickly, it means a week or more

Jeni's ice cream is amazing. They have a variety of unique and delicious flavors using high quality ingredients. It will always be a hit if you bring it to a gathering and makes a great gift. My only complaint is that it is too good that I eat too much of it, too quickly.

One of the best options in the ice-cream aisle of the grocery store! I've had the pleasure of trying Jeni's at one of their scoop shops and I've picked up numerous pints in an assortment of flavors, and I have yet to be disappointed in the quality. While it's typically pricier than some options, you can really taste the difference with the ingredients they use. My personal favorite is the Wild-berry Lavender, which is a bit unusual at first bite with floral and fruity notes, but it quickly takes on an addicting quality. The texture is super smooth and creamy, and the mix-ins with other flavors never overpower the actual ice-cream. Balanced is the best way to sum up all of the flavors I've tried.

Jeni’s is absolutely amazing. I had Frosé and it was so refreshing without being overbearingly alcoholic. A perfect sweet treat!

One of my favorite ice cream brands because of the quality of their ice cream and the unique flavor profiles that make you feel like you are eating ice cream like and adult should. The salted caramel is irresistible and better than any other brand I’ve tried.

They've got everything from basic chocolate and vanilla to genuinely challenging flavors you would not expect in ice cream. Is it more than every other ice cream? Yea sure, but you pay for quality. If you're gonna be cheap do it somewhere else, this is well worth the cost.

As a Columbus native, I've been eating Jeni's for years. It's the best.

The most delicious ice cream with such fun and interesting flavors!

The "Sunshine" flavor is hands-down the best ice cream I've ever tasted. I drove 45 minutes to buy some from the nearest Jeni's because it's not available in stores.

Jeni's ice creams taste amazing, and they have seriously addicting flavors. Brambleberry crisp is one of my favorites, sweet creamy ice cream with swirls of tart berry and chunks of crisp topping , unbelievable taste and mouth feel. The seasonal flavors are not to be missed. The non dairy varieties are just as good or better than some dairy full versions. I like that Jeni's uses grass fed dairy and local ingredients. Woman owned, also they are a certified B corp which is awesome.

I am an ice cream connoisseur. I eat it almost every day, so I have tried a lot of ice creams on the market. I thought Jeni's would be overrated at first, but I was wrong! Their flavors keep me coming back for more - there's always something different to try and are more unique than some other brands on the shelf. I also love the packaging!

This is the best ice cream I've ever had. Plain and simple. Truly blown away.

Favorite ice cream, by far. I'm especially a fan of the salted caramel!

different spin on ice cream. I was very pleased

The range of flavors are amazing and really hit the spot. Definitely one of my favorite ice creams.

Jeni’s ice cream is delicious and has a nostalgic, old timey feel to it. The ice cream is decadent and I appreciate that they offer vegan options. Jeni’s can also be shipped as a fun, special gift.

I love Jeni's ice cream, and since it's not super local to me, I order it online 2 or 3 times a year and it always makes me happy to know I have a few pints in the freezer. I love their Frose the most but I always try their seasonal flavors too.

The best ice cream I've ever had. With the number of flavors provided, there is something for everyone.

My top ice cream shop. I love the creative flavors, my favorite is wildberry lavender and darkest chocolate.

Jeni's is one of my favorite ice creams! I love the creative flavors and super fresh taste. If I had to pick a favorite it would be the Goat Cheese with Red Cherries.