Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

I've been in Columbus, for the last decade, and it's been pretty fun to see the growth of Jeni's coming from its relatively humble origins to the distribution it has today. You can't help but notice the quality no matter which flavor you try. From classic flavors to whacky seasonal ones, there's a certain approachable and elevated nature to its recipes. At a first glance it comes across a little pricey, but compared to others at the top end of the range, it still manages to stand out.

Love the unique flavors of the ice cream, but sometimes it’s difficult to track down a specific pint I want to try. Some flavors are a bit sweet for my liking and they are quite pricey compared to other brands at the store - good once in a while treat though.

The bramble berry ice cream is a constantly stocked item in our house. It’s so good! Love that they have lots of dairy free options

Jeni's is my favorite ice cream of all time. It's creamier and more complex than any other ice cream out there.

Really like this ice cream. A bit pricey but usually worth it. Heads up: while the gooey butter cake flavor is marked "gluten-free" I've felt horrible each time I tried it so maybe be careful if you have a sensitivity!

Love that they sell these because I used to only be able to get in the South. They have so many flavors and have not found one that I don’t like.

I love this icecream. Birthday cake is my fav.

This ice cream is on par with Van Leuwen and salt and straw. The birthday cake flavor is delicious.

Delicious ice cream that paved the way for other brands. I've bought Jeni's for over a decade. So many others have followed in their footsteps with creative flavors and high quality ingredients but Jeni's still shines. I especially love their Brambleberry Crisp and Salted Peanut BUtter.

The only ice cream my kids want - it spoils you to have the best product as you can't go back to mediocre.

Fun, unique, and delicious flavors! As a visitor of their Nashville store, it’s really great to see them expand into grocery stores. Some of the tastiest ice cream I’ve ever had.

Brambleberry Crisp is a league ahead of the other flavors. Jeni knows her stuff.

Explorative and very creative flavors that no other supermarket ice cream brands can beat. I love the packaging design as well.

Nothing compares to Jeni’s! My family’s favorite ice cream!

Best supermarket ice cream option out there in my opinion. Jeni's strikes the balance of fun flavors, great texture, and reasonable price point!

Worth the money - texas sheet cake is one of my favorite flavors of all time

One of my favorite ice creams on the market. The almond brittle is my favorite. The cinnamon roll and brambleberry are also incredible. The blueberry lemon flavor is great for summer. I can’t wait for the scoop shop to open near me!

SUCH yummy flavors. and beautiful packaging!!

Delicious! We had our first Jeni’s experience while visiting Nashville and it really is as good as people say. Highly recommend.

My relationship is in constant orbit around jenis lol. It used to be our date spot and now we love ordering seasonal drops.