Eclipse

Run, don't walk to the nearest store near you that has Eclipse. This ice cream is dairy-free but is among one of the best ice cream brands I've ever had! I actually had to do a double-take and look at the label again to make sure I read it correctly. Obsessed with the chocolate peanut butter flavor. So so good. (Other brands I like for context--Jeni's ice cream, Milk's Cereal Milk ice cream)

Nothing -- this ice cream is perfect.

I worked at an ice cream shop for several years, so I'm no stranger to the dairy game. Eclipse is among the best ice cream I've ever had -- dairy-free or otherwise. I wouldn't be surprised if their cookie butter flavor becomes a classic like Phish Food or Half Baked.