Coterie reviews and discussion

3.9

72% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Ultra-soft diaper material
  • High-absorption diaper core
  • Minimalist, elegant design
  • Large, durable wipes
  • Inconsistent fit across sizes
  • Scratchy, fragile pant sides
  • Bulky diaper silhouette
  • Occasional leaks and blowouts

Coterie earns mixed reviews: the brand delivers exceptionally soft, absorbent diapers and standout wipes, but fit issues, leaks, and rashes surface for some babies—especially after walking or in certain sizes. Reviews praise the minimalist design, gentle wipes, strong tapes, and overnight performance for some, while calling out scratchy pant sides, bulky cuts, inconsistent absorption, and significant concerns around accessibility and hype versus performance.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

30 reviews and posts

  • Coterie is very hard to do business with. Their diapers cannot be returned even when they sent me a package of diapers in the wrong size. I found it almost impossible to change the order to the correct size. They cannot be reached by phone. Their whole system appears to be set up to make it easy for them to take our money. also: Coterie Baby Inc., a self-described high-performance baby products company, convinced a federal judge to dismiss a proposed class action alleging it misled consumers by advertising its diapers were free from harmful chemicals despite containing PFAS. PFAS are not acceptable for putting next to our baby's tender skin. I have been an Honest subscriber for 3 years and found their customer service to be excellent. I was able to return unopened packages when the baby grew. Their diapers do not contain PFAS. These Coterie diapers are expensive and the company used deceptive business practices.

    No discount.
  • Yes yes yes! We love Coterie diapers and I think they are also great for overnights as well. They are so lux and worth paying the extra $ for!

  • They're marketed as affordable but I don't consider that accurate and I'm not sure most people would. I've tried them, they're great and very absorbent but the price is unsustainable. There is another similar option available at Target for cheaper.

  • My daughter went almost an entire year without getting a single diaper rash, one week after switching to these she got the worst diaper dermatitis I have ever seen. She was in so much pain. We went to three doctors who all misdiagnosed her with a yeast infection. Finally got her to a dermatologist who asked if we had switched her diaper recently and a lightbulb went off. Stopped using Coterie and the rash cleared up in 48 hours. Super expensive and she still had leaks on top of it. Not worth the money

  • We love Coterie and have been using them for or the last four months. Baby is now seven months old and we've never had a diaper rash or redness that didn't go away within the day. We've tried other popular brands along with Honest, Millie Moon and Dyper, but Coterie fit our baby's body shape the best without having too much extra diaper around the bottom. With other brands even when the diapers looked like a large fit poop would still blow out the back or front. We've already sized up twice and apart from a few newborn diapers we haven't had a front/back blowout in months. There have been a few side leaks but that was after baby had been going wild in his activity center. The tape fastener is really strong and sometimes I get it snagged on the new diaper as I'm pulling the old one away, not really an inconvenience though. They're plain white on the outside so it's easy to see the wetness indicators. The outside is also very soft and doesn't feel plasticky or waxy, just a soft-to-the-touch material. The inner cuff is also frilly and looks really cute. These diapers are absolutely a luxury but I think you get what you pay for with them.

  • I definitely think this brand should be in more stores!! My baby had a bad diaper rash and we switched to this brand due to that. I was so impressed by quality and texture of the diaper itself. We added wipes to our subscription and were equally impressed. They are fragrance free and multipurpose with a nice amount of moisture to them. Again, these should be in more stores!

    Feedback

    Accessibility in more stores

    A consumer
  • It’s bad. It’s not absorbent. My daughter is 6 weeks old and never had a rash. The third day we started using this diapers, she had rashes :( Her bottom was al red, she got really fussy, I was very upset about it.

  • I was looking for a diaper brand that didn’t have a smell and was still soft. Tried Coterie and wasn’t disappointed. Super soft and absorbent and really liked the lack of gendered designs.

    Feedback

    The price point was slightly high. It is a quality product but it’s not sustainable to buy with other expenses and needs.