Ben & Jerry's

Ben & Jerry's

Ben & Jerry's reviews and discussion

4.6

100% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Ultra-creamy texture excellence
  • Generous mix-ins distribution
  • Iconic, crowd-pleasing flavors
  • Consistent, high-quality craftsmanship
  • Non-dairy flavor inconsistency
  • Occasionally monotonous taste
  • Overly sweet formulations
  • Limited new flavor variety

Ben & Jerry’s earns strong reviews and clearly delivers: the ice cream tastes rich, ultra‑creamy, and loaded with generous mix‑ins across beloved flavors like Cherry Garcia, Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Americone Dream, and The Tonight Dough. Reviews also flag drawbacks—non‑dairy pints taste inferior or monotonous, flavors can be intensely sweet, and some wish for more variety—so it’s a decadent, crowd‑pleasing choice with caveats for plant‑based options and sugar intensity.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

31 reviews and posts

  • I have tried a bunch of the non dairy Ben and Jerry's flavors and I think that they definitely taste different than their dairy versions. I liked this one and thought it tasted good but halfway through the flavor got very monotonous.

  • I tried the Ben & Jerry's Sunday in Cookie Vermont-ster variety and it was really delicious. There were multiple layers involved. There was a whipped top layer with chocolate swirls. The middle part was ice cream with lots of cookie bits and other chocolate bites. Honestly one of the best flavors I've had. It was such a decadent dessert pairing all cookie bits together well.

  • I love Ben and Jerry's ice cream. The cherry Garcia flavor is well known for a reason and I have always liked trying their other flavor combinations as well. Ice cream quality is good for it being a brand that doesn't cost a lot.

  • I am a gelato girl through and through but when I'm wanting an ice cream moment, B&J is where it is at. I visited their factory a few years ago for my birthday and it was super cool to see how the ice cream was created. Cherry Garcia will forever have my heart. <3

  • Ben & Jerry's is not only delicious ice cream; I have immense admiration for their strong beliefs and values as a company regarding everything from racial justice to climate impact. Also, their flavors are just fun. They have such various options, and I have yet to find a flavor I did not enjoy.

  • I've never had their pint of their ice cream but I got to try the little snackable cookie dough bites, which I enjoyed (but were gone too soon). These would be really good as ice cream toppings or ninja creami mix ins.

  • I have always loved Ben & Jerry’s for their company values. Their ice cream is truly the best. I tried this new sundaes variety recently and I really liked it. It’s a cool concept from a great company.

  • I don't eat a lot of regular (i.e. not low sugar) ice cream but when/if I do, I love Ben & Jerry's Americone Dream, which is vanilla ice cream with fudge-covered waffle cone pieces and a caramel swirl. ben & Jerry's is an iconic ice cream maker with a plethora of other amazing flavors, too.

  • Love their ice cream and always go on sale at the grocery store!

  • I like this brand because it offers high-quality ice cream that doesn't get into the realm of being too expensive. I love that they offer a ton of different flavors and even a good number of plant-based options.

  • Ben & Jerry's never disappoints! The ice cream is creamy, rich, and packed with bold flavors that hit every time. Whether you're a fan of classics like Cherry Garcia or something more adventurous, they’ve got it all. The chunks and swirls in every bite take it to another level. It’s the perfect indulgence, and honestly, I can never stop at just one scoop. Highly recommend if you’re craving top-notch ice cream!

  • It’s a classic brand you can count on. I like that the quality is always good and the price matches that. I wish they came out with more flavors though

  • LOVE BEN AND JERRYS!! There ice creams are a grocery store go tos. There is something for everyone. Some of the best cookie dough ice cream I’ve tasted. Gives a statisfying amount of toppings!

  • the vegan ones are SO BAD (literally avoid with ur life) but i love regular cherry garcia + half baked!

  • The best. Love all their different flavors!

  • For the few flavours I've tasted, can say it's yummy ice cream for sure. But it's definitely a treat yoself kind of ice cream because that's the only way I can justify the cost for the amount, even though it's good ice cream, it's expensive.

  • Ben and Jerry's ice cream is one of my favorite ice creams. It is very rich and creamy and feels very decadent because of how well it's made. They have just the right amount of mix-ins for the ice cream and it is always a perfect balance throughout the ice cream, from the last bite to the first

  • Gimme Smore is the best ice cream flavor to ever exist. They are super high in sugar and calories but they can always fulfill your cravings. I also love the Mint Chocolate Cookie and Chocolate Fudge Brownie flavors.

  • Absolute 10/10 for store bought ice cream! Very unique flavors with an ultra creamy taste! Great company initiatives as well (extremely charitable in MANY ways!) They use fair trade and other ethical practices, so yes a little more pricey, but well worth it!